3 ms·
I think making it personal like that would cause a great many more problems than it would solve. For articles, I upvote them as a means to "save" them. I thin
by Mz 17y ago
I think making it personal like that would cause a great many more problems than it would solve. For articles, I upvote them as a means to "save" them. I think that's a more objective means to measure value: I vote on articles to serve my own needs (because I value them), not to express an opinion or agreement/disagreement. I have no idea what could be done to the system of voting on individual comments which would more closely align to that rubric.
I would rather not know if some individual is routinely downvoting me. There is no way to determine if such a pattern arises out of personal dislike/spitefulness or just coincidence that they see the world very differently from me and therefore just happen to strongly disagree with many things I say. But the ability to check for/notice such patterns would likely begin negatively impacting discussions here as it would promote "feuds" which likely would not remain confined to voting patterns. I've seen a few comments that suggest that there are running battles here between specific individuals, but you get that everywhere and it seems less toxic and less obvious here than what I have witnessed elsewhere.
For that matter, it also might not be a good thing to know one person routinely upvotes someone in particular.
- ytinas 17y ago>or just coincidence that they see the world very differently from me and therefore just happen to strongly disagree with many things I say But they are not supposed to down vote for strongly disagreeing. Down vote means "this person is not contributing to the discussion". Down vote is supposed to discourage the person from doing what ever they did again. So what message does the current environment send? Think like everyone else or you're not welcome here? Seems like exactly the opposite of what a start up oriented site would want.
- Mz 17y agoRegardless of what the intent is, you cannot control people and there are people here who have publicly stated they downvote people for reasons like "I was downvoted and I'm upset about it". Which is why I remarked on the fact that I upvote articles to meet my own needs -- to "save" them -- and I don't know how you would make the comment voting intrinsically related to what people value rather than just opinion, momentary bad moods, etc. I raised two gifted-learning disabled sons and if there was a way to either misunderstand the rules or find some loophole, they would do so. I am a firm believer in designing the system so it does what it is supposed to do and not counting on people seeing the world the same way I do, having the same values I have, "agreeing" to a particular set of rules/ethics/social mores...etc. I don't know how to get there with the voting system on this site but I don't think making it public how people vote would be an improvement. That's just my 2 cents, of course.