4 ms·
> Problem is that they contradict each other and we have no way to combine them in ways that make sense philosophically No, that's not true. The classical wor
by lisper 11y ago
> Problem is that they contradict each other and we have no way to combine them in ways that make sense philosophically
No, that's not true. The classical world is an emergent property of the quantum world, and the manner in which it arises is perfectly well understood. It's just that the popular press has not gotten the memo.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dEaecUuEqfc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dEaecUuEqfc
http://www.flownet.com/ron/QM.pdf http://www.flownet.com/ron/QM.pdf
- jerf 11y agoI think that presentation tries to explain why entanglement is less mysterious than it seems. I'm broadly a proponent of demystifying QM, myself; see also Quantum Computing Since Democritus, especially Lecture 9: http://www.scottaaronson.com/democritus/lec9.html http://www.scottaaronson.com/democritus/lec9.html , for instance, for the sort of thing I mean. QM is not really "simple" but we really ought to be past the "woo woo" phase by now. It does nothing to resolve the other issues, like the quantum field's mass becoming greater than observed at the scale of the universe or other fundamental issues. Relativity and QM as we currently understand them really are at odds with each other and it's not just an interpretation thing.
- lisper 11y agoThe comment to which I was responding specifically referred to the "contradiction" of locality. That has to do with entanglement. It's true that reconciling GR and QM is still an unsolved problem, and obviously I have nothing substantive to say about that (if I did I'd win the Nobel prize :-)
- jerf 11y agoAh, my apologies. In that case class this under vehement agreement. :)
- ThomPete 11y agoThats interpretation of QM not QM itself as such no?. Unless someone who know a lot more than I do tells me thats wrong I will go with what I have been told and read. I am aware that many people want to demystify it or overmystify it, but the basic facts as far as I understand them are still that there are no interpretation of QM that satisfies everything and to the extent that it does you can't predict with it (like string theory) This is not something that can be explained with the press didn't get the memo. Some very smart people have spent decades on this and still not come to a conclusion. I have heard many such attempts to brush it off as a non-issue. I still haven't found anything satisfactory even to my un-educated understanding of it.
- lisper 11y ago> Thats interpretation of QM not QM itself as such no? Depends on what you mean. The explanation of how classical reality emerges from the wave function is mathematical. Once you understand that you will understand why the apparent "contradiction" between classical locality and quantum non-locality isn't a contradiction any more than Newton's absolute space and time is a "contradiction" of Einstein's relative space and time. Classical reality is an approximation that holds under certain circumstances (systems with a large number of mutually entangled degrees of freedom), just a Newtonian mechanics is an approximation that holds under certain circumstances (low velocities and low spacetime curvature).
- ThomPete 11y agoYou are interpreting to come to the conclusion "that the press didn't get the memo". But that is ultimately the difference. One predicts a discrete universe the other the opposite. Both are true but can't be reconciled without introducing all sorts of issues. This was an attempt to do a tl;dr. Some people will disagree with you that it's no big mystery but you both agree on the math and experimental data. And that shows two differen't "universes" That is at least my understanding which admittedly is a lay mans understanding, but I have read enough and followed enough discussions to know that not everyone agrees with your memo characterization :)