6 ms·
Is there still a valid reason to have timezones altering between states? is it just for agriculture? While we're, talking about changing time monitoring system
by dijit 11y ago
Is there still a valid reason to have timezones altering between states? is it just for agriculture?
While we're, talking about changing time monitoring systems, can't we have 13 months with 28 days each? (and an extra day every 4 years added on to december?) :(
Simple things, but that would allow us to follow the lunar cycle.
- germanier 11y agoIt's a bit cumbersome to have the calender date changing during our work period. Just consider all the contracts that end on a given date.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 11y agoThey did that many moons ago.
- halefx 11y agoI really like the Hanke-Henry calendar https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanke-Henry_Permanent_Calendar https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanke-Henry_Permanent_Calend...
- hellbanner 11y agoI asked farmers about this. They said it was stupid now that we have electricity. And even then, with the shorter days.. it was still stupid. (I'm quoting them)
- protomyth 11y agoI wish people would quit repeating the farmer myth. No farmer I have met wants daylight savings time. Look at Indiana for some perspective. Farm animals do not have watches.
- ctdonath 11y agoFarm animals do not have watches. As a parent: Neither do small children.
- acacia314 11y agoUgh, time changes with children...suck.
- hellbanner 11y agoCan we start a movement to end this nonsense?
- mikestew 11y agoJust because Indiana doesn't have DST now (for most of the state, anyway) doesn't mean they've always never had it. There was DST when I was growing up in the 70s, and they got rid of it long after agriculture was no longer the primary industry in Indiana. Having grown up in Indiana farm country, I'm of the opinion that "DST because farmers" has always been a myth. One gets up with the sun no matter the time. You quit work when it's dark. Oh, wait, that's not true, either. With the advent of electric lighting on vehicles about, oh, 100 years ago, lack of sun no longer need keep one from the fields. I recall many a late night that the farmer that owned the field next to us was out either tilling or harvesting, lights ablazin' on the front of the tractor or combine. So we've eliminated the farmer myth, why do we have DST? Few like it, do I...follow the money?
- jcranmer 11y agoThe main justification for DST is that it saves energy. The actual evidence of this claim is rather mixed, although even reports that show that DST saved energy aren't necessarily finding that the reduced costs make up for the mere cost of having to switch clocks twice a year (which itself isn't particularly well-quantified).
- Jtsummers 11y agoThe history of DST is distinct from agriculture, it was more strongly connected to factory work. It's easier to have every employee change their clock by an hour than change the schedule twice a year. However, we've moved away from the need (mostly) for the potential energy savings, though perhaps for the wrong reasons (we work in offices and factories with little natural light). The remaining reason to keep it is to allow people access to daylight after their normal work hours. But this can be accomplished by shifting schedules. Move the standard start of work from 7 to 6:30, split the difference. And if that seems intractable, shift our time zones by 30 minutes and be done with it.
- pwg 11y ago> So we've eliminated the farmer myth, why do we have DST? One likely possibility is the "but that is the way it has always been done" response (http://www.jeffbridges.com/because.html http://www.jeffbridges.com/because.html).
- cbd1984 11y agoAlso, the extra hour of daylight utterly destroys the crops.
- DanAndersen 11y agoOur timezone/calendar system is convoluted, but that's because there are inherent issues with any calendar reform. I recommend looking at the following articles: http://qntm.org/abolish http://qntm.org/abolish ("So you want to abolish time zones") http://qntm.org/calendar http://qntm.org/calendar ("You advocate a ________ approach to calendar reform")
- Navarr 11y agoAll of these are valid points but when we get the ability to force the earth's rotation, orbit, and the moon's orbit to specifics then I WILL SHOW YOU.
- fweespeech 11y agoHey, when you have the power to hold the whole Earth for ransom, remember to ask for $1 million dollars. ;)
- jerf 11y agoThat's just a special case of http://qntm.org/destroy http://qntm.org/destroy . qntm's got you comprehensively covered here.
- bostonpete 11y agoIn Northern areas, there's a lot of practical value that gets overlooked. In Boston, the sun is rising close to 5:00 AM as it is at the height of summer. Without daylight savings time, it would be rising at 4:00 AM. I think most people would rather have extended daylight late in the day than have all that extra sunlight wasted when we're sleeping. The counter to that is -- well, let's always stick with daylight savings time then. That has problems of its own. For example, sunset is a little after 4:00 PM in Boston in late December. If we stuck with daylight savings time, it'd be a little after 3:00. That would pose risks for school children walking home, etc. Yes, I realize that people in Fairbanks Alaska have it much worse and daylight savings doesn't fix the problem for them, but there are a lot of people who live in the northern parts of the lower 48 that benefit from the time shift.
- BookmarkSaver 11y ago> For example, sunset is a little after 4:00 PM in Boston in late December. If we stuck with daylight savings time, it'd be a little after 3:00. This seems backwards. Sunset would be after 5 if they kept daylight savings. I used to live in Boston, and I despised how early the sun would set. It made getting off of work demoralizing. I always liked the idea of just switching to Atlantic time. Whatever the case may be, I strongly value daylight later in the day rather than in the morning.
- bostonpete 11y agoYou're right, I got it backwards. The problem would be that kids would be walking to school in the dark -- not any less of a problem though. As it is sunrise is after 7 in the winter (it'd be after 8). In New York it would be even later since they're further west.
- ghaff 11y agoYou're backwards. The problem with year-round daylight savings in Boston (which, personally, I'd prefer) is kids going to school in the dark in the winter. Boston's both relatively northernly and very far east in a timezone because eastern time wraps up the northeast-jutting coast of the US to avoid New England being in its own timezone. [Edit: It wouldn't be in its own timezone; it would be in Atlantic time, which is used in parts of Canada. But it would put Boston in a different timezone from NYC and other major east coast cities.]
- jahewson 11y agoYou're confusing time zones with daylight savings. Time zones exist so that the same part of the solar day has approximately the same time associated with it wherever you are in the world (prior to the railroads, that was the only time - local time). So I can say "it's 4am in China" and you'll know it's the middle of the night without having to consult Google. They can also achieve the opposite, keeping neighbours on the same time when their solar days are actually different, e.g. within China. Sometimes that's useful. Daylight savings exist for saving power (and were introduced in the war to do just this), providing more daylight hours for school children, and longer days for agriculture (now historic). There is debate about whether any of those reasons are actually valid.
- eterm 11y agoExcept China has a single timezone, so "4am in China" doesn't mean as much as you think it might.
- fweespeech 11y agohttp://www.theatlantic.com/china/archive/2013/11/china-only-has-one-time-zone-and-thats-a-problem/281136/ http://www.theatlantic.com/china/archive/2013/11/china-only-... Ah yes, but they didn't always.
- mjevans 11y agoThe fact that you just said this, in this context, shows me how clearly embedded the AM/PM 'standard' is for people. Though that doesn't mean it's still a good idea to use it for meetings. It just signals to me that the only way of displacing this imprecise messy standard is to teach people to schedule meetings differently; and to have their smartphones display both the AM/PM time, and the standard meetings time. Unfortunately that would probably still be as a 'timezone', and if we're doing that it may as well just be UTC since every timezone library I've every used already has that and best of all is only off by a few seconds at most without updates. (Close enough for applications that care about timezones instead of leap seconds.)
- phirschybar 11y agoHa. What is your solution for existing birthdays?
- sdkmvx 11y agoNot that I would advocate confusing matters by changing the calendar again, but you just move the birthdays same as last time. From Wikipedia: George Washington (February 22, 1732 [O.S. February 11, 1731] – December 14, 1799) Notice the year is different. In the British Empire before 1752, March 25th was the first day of the year. March 24, 1751 was the day before March 25, 1752. Then September 2, 1752 was the day before September 14, 1752 The last day of 1752 was December 31, and the calendar has continued how we consider normal ever since. The British custom of starting the tax year on April 6th survives as a relic of the old calendar (March 25th plus the missing 12 days in 1752).
- qntm 11y agoActually you'd need December to have one extra day every year and a second extra day every 4 years. And the months still wouldn't sync up with the synodic month, because the synodic month doesn't evenly divide the solar year no matter what you do.
- harryh 11y ago13 * 28 = 364 not 365. So you'd need an extra day every year and 2 extra days every 4 years. What we really need to do is use some rockets to slightly slow down the rotation of the earth so that a day is exactly 1/360th of a year. All kinds of numbers divide evenly into 360 so that should make building a good calendar easy.
- Roodgorf 11y agoWhile it wouldn't exactly follow the lunar cycle as the parent mentions, there are already proposed calendars similar to what you mention[1]. Of course, with any calendar readjustment come just as many drawbacks, as the wiki entry mentions some. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Fixed_Calendar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Fixed_Calendar
- harryh 11y agoI'm disappointed that this wiki page mentions no drawbacks to my plan to slow down the rotation of the earth. I've no idea what they would be, but I'm guessing that this might come with some negative repercussions.
- Roodgorf 11y agoIf Wikipedia doesn't know about it, it's probably not important. In light of this new information, I hereby pledge my support for these reformations.