10 ms·
> Headlines like these are obviously created for sensationalism It isn't. Depending on whose numbers you use, the statistic is either actually true or sufficie
by AnthonyMouse 11y ago
> Headlines like these are obviously created for sensationalism
It isn't. Depending on whose numbers you use, the statistic is either actually true or sufficiently close that disputing the difference is pedantry.
The reason the headline is shocking is that people expect there to be relatively few police shootings yet, if the GWoT rhetoric is to be believed, rather a serious problem with terrorism. The fact that the problem of police shootings is larger than the problem of terrorism is a strong, concise, true statement that somewhere along the lines we have our priorities inverted.
In particular, it implies that "fighting terrorism" with more and stronger law enforcement is highly counterproductive.
- Nadya 11y ago>It isn't. Depending on whose numbers you use, the statistic is either actually true or sufficiently close that disputing the difference is pedantry. Sensationalism in this case is saying that 0.00003% > 0.0000009% and expecting people to care. Both scenarios are so absurdly rare as to be disregarded, even if many people are more afraid of terrorists than the police and statistics say it should be the other way around. The following is also true [0]: "More likely to trip down stairs and die than be killed by a shark!" Well.. I'm not about to avoid taking the stairs. Nor am I going to stop being afraid of shark attacks. I know they are both rare and often rarely fatal, at least here in the US [1], but that doesn't mean I'll be less scared of them. [0] http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr64/nvsr64_02.pdf http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr64/nvsr64_02.pdf [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shark_attack https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shark_attack E: Some words.
- pelario 11y agoAgain, it does matter: when to reduce the 0.000000009 the government is increasing the already many times larger 0.000003, it does matter.
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> Both scenarios are so absurdly rare as to be disregarded That's the point. The comparison is interesting because it puts the GWoT in the correct context. It's something to point to when some absurd overreaction to terrorism is proposed -- the police are literally more likely to kill you than the terrorists. Spending less money militarizing the police will make us more safe. Even if the difference in safety is negligible, it takes the safety argument off the table. And the safety argument is the only thing justifying the civil liberties violations and the billions of tax dollars they're wasting.
- conceit 11y ago> > Headlines like these are obviously created for sensationalism > It isn't. > [...] In particular, it implies that "fighting terrorism" with more and stronger law enforcement is highly counterproductive. If police's only job was to fight terrorism, you would be right.