4 ms·
I'm wondering at the actual value of old cases. Surely there's a halflife for law. This worship of precedent as semi-holy writing is strange to me. As an Engine
by JoeAltmaier 11y ago
I'm wondering at the actual value of old cases. Surely there's a halflife for law. This worship of precedent as semi-holy writing is strange to me. As an Engineer, old books are far less useful than new ones. Things change; people change; law changes too. Maybe its just fine the books were mutilated for this process. Its a way of 'burning bridges' and putting it all behind us.
- nekopa 11y agoYou would be surprised at how relevant some of the old case law is. Mainly because it goes straight to the heart of certain issues - i.e. What does it actually mean to 'own'something. These fundamentals don't change, but of course, this modern world does put stress on some of these principles, for example have I really stolen from you if you still have the item? (Digital copying)
- rtkwe 11y agoOld cases are valid so long as the laws haven't changed, there hasn't been a new ruling that overrides that, and the situation is similar. Judges aren't completely bound by precedent either if the situation means it shouldn't apply they're able to rule differently and explain why in their judgements. The concept of precedent is really important in law because of all the vagaries and rules surrounding laws and how their applied, it also supports the even application of the law so that laws and their effects are more predictable. It also makes cases easier for to argue by mapping out the corner cases of the law and legal concepts and keeps every lawyer from having to be an absolute expert in every facet of every case they're litigating. The same applies to judges. Precedents do have a limited lifetime but it's not measured in years, if someone is being tried under the same law as existed 100 years ago old rulings can be just as relevant as one made last year.
- Jtsummers 11y ago> As an Engineer, old books are far less useful than new ones. This isn't always true. Many of the fundamentals of civil engineering, mechanical engineering, mathematics, power engineering, chemistry, physics, even computer science, are not supplanted by more recent texts. In fact, when I was a computer science and math student, I lamented many of the modern texts (math and physics ones being the most egregious) for their overly fluffy delivery, compared to my father's and grandfather's and mother's math textbooks from (at the time) 20 and 60 years earlier. I would use theirs to study because they were much better at conveying the topics than the recent calculus or statistics or whatever book we were given. Now, in industry, and in the software industry in particular, this is more applicable. So much is changing so fast, but the basic concepts (functions, types, network theory, latency versus throughput, even multi-process computing) are the same, but the technologies we use and how they present or make use of these fundamentals change rapidly so my 199x book on javascript is only barely applicable to what we have today.