8 ms·
The Contest Between Gravity and Quantum Physics
- nkrisc 11y agoI thoroughly enjoy reading and learning about this sort of physics, but I still very much lack the understanding to discuss it. So I'll just say that pondering the nature of the universe, that I am just a region of low entropy, that anything I do will have no discernible effect on the universe really makes any problems I have seem like small potatoes!
- ThomPete 11y agoThe completely over-simplistic uneducated TL;DR until someone way more knowledgeable hopefully step in and correct my mistakes. Classically Physics - Everything is local. Quantum Physics - Everything is non-local Both theories are proven to the extent anything can be proven both mathematically and experimentally. Problem is that they contradict each other and we have no way to combine them in ways that make sense philosophically. All attempts have some sort of missing element. Article propose yet another attempt to combine them. My uneducated guess is that somethings not going to be like we thought and we are back to two incompatible models.
- norea-armozel 11y agoMy question is what's going to be 'lost' by the combination of GR/SR with QM? I'm assuming that gravitational singularities will have to go or be re-rationalized. So far, I can't see there's much chance of that happening as long as blackholes retain their ever consistent behavior as we've observed so far.
- empath75 11y agoSpace-time becomes an emergent phenomena, rather than fundamental.
- cygx 11y agoDepends on your point of view: Arguably, the 'stringy' view of space-time is more in line with the bimetric theories of days gone by, with the metric being a field on top of a fixed background.
- jjoonathan 11y agoIsn't SR+QM "just" QFT? I thought it was GR+QM that was troublesome.
- cygx 11y agoThere's also non-relativistic QFT, ie SR+QM != QFT in general. You're right that special relativity has been incorporated into QFT.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- lisper 11y ago> Problem is that they contradict each other and we have no way to combine them in ways that make sense philosophically No, that's not true. The classical world is an emergent property of the quantum world, and the manner in which it arises is perfectly well understood. It's just that the popular press has not gotten the memo. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dEaecUuEqfc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dEaecUuEqfc http://www.flownet.com/ron/QM.pdf http://www.flownet.com/ron/QM.pdf
- jerf 11y agoI think that presentation tries to explain why entanglement is less mysterious than it seems. I'm broadly a proponent of demystifying QM, myself; see also Quantum Computing Since Democritus, especially Lecture 9: http://www.scottaaronson.com/democritus/lec9.html http://www.scottaaronson.com/democritus/lec9.html , for instance, for the sort of thing I mean. QM is not really "simple" but we really ought to be past the "woo woo" phase by now. It does nothing to resolve the other issues, like the quantum field's mass becoming greater than observed at the scale of the universe or other fundamental issues. Relativity and QM as we currently understand them really are at odds with each other and it's not just an interpretation thing.
- lisper 11y agoThe comment to which I was responding specifically referred to the "contradiction" of locality. That has to do with entanglement. It's true that reconciling GR and QM is still an unsolved problem, and obviously I have nothing substantive to say about that (if I did I'd win the Nobel prize :-)
- jerf 11y agoAh, my apologies. In that case class this under vehement agreement. :)
- ThomPete 11y agoThats interpretation of QM not QM itself as such no?. Unless someone who know a lot more than I do tells me thats wrong I will go with what I have been told and read. I am aware that many people want to demystify it or overmystify it, but the basic facts as far as I understand them are still that there are no interpretation of QM that satisfies everything and to the extent that it does you can't predict with it (like string theory) This is not something that can be explained with the press didn't get the memo. Some very smart people have spent decades on this and still not come to a conclusion. I have heard many such attempts to brush it off as a non-issue. I still haven't found anything satisfactory even to my un-educated understanding of it.
- spacehome 11y ago> Quantum Physics - Everything is non-local Not true in the slightest. The Many-Worlds interpretation is local.
- ThomPete 11y agoBut it's an interpretation not the actual mathematical and observational data no? I.e. Bells Theorem predict non-locality. Many worlds is a way to interpret not the actual theory? Or am I wrong?
- spacehome 11y agoContrary to the name, Many Worlds is a complete theory. Bell's Theorem does not predict non-locality, rather it says that any local realist theory must satisfy a certain inequality which is violated in practice. An assumption of Bell's Theorem which is so deep of an assumption that people don't even know they're making it is is that there's only one outcome to any measurement.
- tim333 11y ago>The Many-Worlds interpretation is local I'm not sure it is even though Wikipedia currently says that it is local. The recent experiment http://www.nytimes.com/2015/10/22/science/quantum-theory-experiment-said-to-prove-spooky-interactions.html http://www.nytimes.com/2015/10/22/science/quantum-theory-exp... seems to show clear non local effects. I don't think that contradicts Many-Worlds. Much of the question comes down to an aspect that Everett, the inventor of Many-Worlds kind of hand waved over and didn't really explain. He said roughly lets assume all outcomes happen and assign a probability P to each one without really explaining where the Ps came from. In the NYT described experiment the probabilities seem to be such as to show non local effects but Everett and his theory don't really say much as to how they got that way.
- spacehome 11y agoThe experiment you liked is just a supped up version of the experiments that first showed that Bell's Inequality is violated in our reality. The experiment didn't really have any theoretical import. I don't think anybody really thought that Freedman and Clauser's experimental outcome was due to some "loophole" that, when closed, would let Bell's Inequality be satisfied. And despite what the experimenters seem to believe, the experiment you linked to does not show non-local effects. That's not really the way that science and experimentation work. The experimental result rules out a particular class of physical theory - specifically any theory that's local and real, but a deep assumption of the derivation (so deep that one doesn't realize one is making it) is that every measurement has one outcome, which of course Many Worlds does not assume. I don't think that anyone is hand waving about where probabilities come from -- they are the integral of the squared modulus of the wave function. Nothing ambiguous about the mathematics of the theory. If you're asking why this equation rather than some other equation, it's an open question, and an interesting one. But the Many Worlds Theory can perfectly well do its job as a predictor of experiment without justification of where the equation comes from. You may as well ask "Why the Schrodinger Equation rather than some other equation?". It's also worth pointing out that all interpretations of QM have the same open question because they all have some form of the Born Rule without justification.
- _-__--- 11y agoBut, of course: the relative volume of events is somewhat tapered by space-like interactions. Me not paying rent this weekend would mean a lot more to my present state in life - insofar as I am able to perceive it - than a hypothetical supernova event occurring on the far end of Andromeda. I am under no illusion that the tediums of my life are more significant that the potential destruction of an entire anonymous solar system, but when conditioned on my own experience it seems a bit more pertinent. I'd posit that it's the recognition of this conditioning operation that let's us get a wider/better perspective on things.
- smoyer 11y agoIf a star explodes in an obscure galaxy and no one observes it, does it have an impact one anyone's existence?
- zardo 11y agoIt could influence whether or not someone exists in the future. Some star in an obscure galaxy went supernova, and none of us would be here if it hadn't.
- jeffwass 11y agoDepends, did the life forms living in that obscure galaxy not observe it because the explosion eradicated them faster than their sensory observations could tell the explosion was happening? Ie, even if the explosion occurred on a much faster time scale than their sensory biology, and thus wiped out their planets in an effective instant, I'd argue it made an impact even though no one was left to observe it.
- ThomPete 11y agoimpact on who? Doens't the very idea of impact require some sort of mind to understand the impact? In a world with no observers there wouldn't be any event's because there wouldn't be any perspectives to interpret it from.
- 11y ago
- ISL 11y agoAn important nitpick: the description of the equivalence principle [1] in the article is incorrect. A spinning astronaut in a universe without stars can discern whether she or her partner is spinning, particularly if they work together a little. The astronaut can change her moment of inertia by curling into a ball or spreading out: if the astronauts' relative rotation rate changes, she's rotating. If it doesn't, she's not. Things are more complicated if they're both rotating, but with mental math and freshman/high-school physics, they'll be able to sort it out completely. Even in a universe without any external reference, it's possible to place limits on your rotation rate. If a centrifugal force is palpable when extending an appendage, then you're rotating. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equivalence_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equivalence_principle
- kipple 11y agoWouldn't that be explained by the next paragraph? > The distinction between the two astronauts makes sense only when you reintroduce the rest of the universe. In the classic interpretation of general relativity, then, inertia exists only because you can measure it against the entire cosmic gravitational field. This seems like a case of a spherical cow[1], the thought experiment is simplified down to only these two astronauts. No fabric of space around them, and so no inertia. Perhaps it would have been less confusing if the thought experiment had used two normal people floating in nothingness? The presence of spacesuits makes it seem like they exist within some sort of reasonable environment. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spherical_cow https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spherical_cow
- ISL 11y agoThe "reintroduction of the rest of the universe" is a euphemistic introduction of the general idea of Mach's Principle [1]. Such an idea is certainly possible, and physically interesting, but nobody's yet figured out how to test it. A well-motivated and compelling experiment to test Mach's Principle would be worthwhile and a lot of fun. The current, locally-determined, laws of physics would produce the same outcomes for our rotating astronauts with or without the presence of anything else in the universe. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mach%27s_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mach%27s_principle
- selimthegrim 11y agoSmolin lost all credibility with me after I read this blogpost by Jacques Distler https://golem.ph.utexas.edu/~distler/blog/archives/002645.html#c044480 https://golem.ph.utexas.edu/~distler/blog/archives/002645.ht... (this is a comment, scroll up for the post)
- peter303 11y agoA similar experiment is being used to ask whether we live inside a digital computer simulation, AKA The Matrix. Both situations would be "pixelated". But one would be due to the fundamental fabric of space-time and the other to The Architect running the simulation. I wonder if there are experiments to distinguish the two.