7 ms·
10 days deserved vs 25 years undeserved? It's a joke. He should serve at least 25 years too.
by pmontra 11y ago
10 days deserved vs 25 years undeserved? It's a joke. He should serve at least 25 years too.
- weddpros 11y agoand he should be ordered to give back 25 years of his own salary to that poor guy
- de_Selby 11y agoExactly, I can't believe this is being billed as a success of the legal system.
- codyb 11y agoIt's the first time it's ever happened. While it may not be justice to the man who served 25 years for a crime he didn't commit, it is a step forward and will serve as a ruling for future trials with similar circumstance.
- struppi 11y agoI agree that 10 days is very short for what he did. But the other part of your comment, "He should serve at least 25 years too", does not sound right to me either. I think that the primary goal of court scentences should not be revenge, but "justice". Whatever that means. The possibility of punishment should be there to deter people from committing crimes. And they should be there so that after a crime, society can say: "See, we are serious about this. We do not want people to do those things". So, the "revenge" thinking (with the extreme of "Take one life, and we'll kill you") does not seem right to me. Also, AFAIK, it was not designed into our juridical system - Which was designed to get past the "eye for an eye" system that was there before. I also think that the primary goal of our prisons should be to re-integrate people into society, not punish them, but this is a completely different topic... Edit: Clarified "The possibility of punishment should be there to deter"
- lultimouomo 11y agoAnd I think many studies have shown that it's the probability of getting caught that dissuades from a crime, much more than the severity of the punishment. How many prosecutors would hide evidence if they had even a 10% chance of getting caught, going to jail for 10 days and loose their career, like it happened in this case? That's what's important in my opinion.
- davem8 11y ago> The punishment should be there to deter others from committing crimes Punishing people for the hypothetical future crimes of others! Is that "Justice".
- struppi 11y agoThanks, I updated my post to clarify what I meant. Disclaimer: English is not my mother tongue, so I am sometimes not precise enough.
- philh 11y agoAnother aspect that I haven't seen much discussion of, is: punishment is there partly to stop other people from exacting it. Situation one: A kills B, B's brother kills A, A's brother kills B's brother... and eventually A's family and friends and B's family and friends are just killing other all the time. Situation two: A kills B, the state kills A. Done. B's family has nobody left to kill, and A's family isn't likely to try to fight the state. This suggests that the state can't make punishments too lenient, or people will take matters into their own hands again. It's not stable.
- lmz 11y agoYes, in exchange for giving the state a monopoly on violence, people need reassuring that the state is going to dispense an appropriate amount of it when required.
- rday 11y agoHow about holding the prosecutor responsible for the 1988 murder by Mark Norwood[0]. Norwood's DNA was found at the scene. Maybe some more investigation in the Morton case(opposed to sitting on evidence) would have put Norwood in jail before he committed the 1988 crime. But certainly, if Michael Morton was never wrongfully convicted, that DNA would have been matched to the Morton murder and this would have been solved decades ago. [0] http://www.texasmonthly.com/articles/mark-alan-norwood-found-guilty-of-christine-mortons-murder/ http://www.texasmonthly.com/articles/mark-alan-norwood-found...
- kriro 11y agoWell at least that means he also had to give up his license to practice law.
- johnpowell 11y agoThank god.. Now he can't work for the few years before he would have retired anyway.
- polymatter 11y agoFYI he had retired. Taking away his license is purely symbolic and entirely consistent with this light tap on the wrist.
- Asbostos 11y agoAs I understand, Americans vote for their local prosecutors or at least judges (this guy ended up as a judge). So keep in mind that the blame ultimately lies with the people of that locality who let such things happen even when they're discovered.
- RogerL 11y agoHow am I, a voter, supposed to know that long ago somebody hid something that wasn't even able to be discovered in the court he was in at the time?
- hwstar 11y agoProsecutors in general are not elected, but the district attorney (Who oversees the prosecutors) is an elected official. And you are correct, the American electorate wants blood and says "Lock 'em up and weld the door shut" when it comes to electing a District Attorney.
- granos 11y agoHe also lost his license to practice law and this case now serves as a sentencing precedent for such crimes committed in the future. Anderson, being in his 60's, probably wouldn't be practicing for too much longer anyway. The next important step is to get judges to issue standing 'ethical rule orders' as mentioned in the article. That way other malicious prosecutors can be help accountable and removed from practicing much earlier. Also, I'd be shocked if this didn't open Anderson up to civil liability. That's where Morton can seek damages; not in criminal court.
- JupiterMoon 11y ago> Also, I'd be shocked if this didn't open Anderson up to civil liability. That's where Morton can seek damages; not in criminal court. Interesting Anderson took a large part of Morton's life. Maybe justice would be served if Morton took a large part of Anderson's money... Something feels uncomfortable about this but I can't quite place it.
- Jtsummers 11y agoPerhaps because it sounds like blood money. Which has the unfortunate affect of being useful for those with wealth to avoid punishment, but useless for those without, who will still end up in prison. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blood_money_(restitution) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blood_money_(restitution)
- JupiterMoon 11y agoThat's the word I was looking for. What about if the penalty was in some way proportional to the wealth/income of the perpetrator?
- Jtsummers 11y agoI don't know the answer to that. Perhaps some more research is in order, I imagine that countries and societies that have this actually codified may already have implemented something like this.
- TheCondor 11y agoAnd this emotional reaction is the root of the problem. When that original crime happened, the public demanded someone jailed, it didn't matter that it wasn't the criminal. Society is hung up on the retribution, so long as that's the case, prosecutors don't need criminals, just patsies that can't properly defend themselves or exhibit social flaws.