6 ms·
Medication errors found in half of surgeries
- Bud 11y agoFrom the article: “Errors” were defined as any kind of mistake in the process of ordering or administering a drug or an adverse drug event, which includes harm or injury to a patient related to a drug, whether or not it was caused by an error.
- belovedeagle 11y agoHow else could they conduct this study? It would be completely meaningless if observers had to second-guess after an observed harm or injury whether or not it was an "error" or just bad luck. It makes no sense to catalogue interactions which could have caused harm (but may or may not have done so) while ignoring the ones which did cause harm (but weren't obviously errors).
- johncolanduoni 11y agoThen the headline shouldn't call them all errors, if they do not have evidence that they were in fact errors. "Medication errors or adverse reactions found in 1 out of 2 surgeries" is a less sexy but actually accurate title.
- cowsandmilk 11y ago80% of their "errors" were actual errors. So, the number drops to 1 out of 3 surgeries for "Preventable Medication Errors".
- Fomite 11y agoThere's a method known as "chart review" that's meant for exactly this purpose - essentially reviewing the evidence available to see if the same decision would have been made. It's expensive, but doable.
- vpribish 11y ago"Of the almost 3,675 medication administrations in the observed operations, 193 events, involving 153 medication errors and 91 adverse drug events, were recorded ... Almost 80 percent of those events were determined to have been preventable. One-third of the observed medication errors led to an adverse drug event, and the remainder had the potential to cause an adverse event. Of the adverse drug events that were recorded, 20 percent were not associated with a medication error." that tangle resolves to: 3,675 observations 122 (3.3%) preventable medication errors 31 (0.8%) un-preventable errors 18 (0.05%) adverse drug events not caused by medication error 3% preventable error rate is shocking - but does include things like documentation problems as well as incorrect dosage btw, the clickbait headline (which is Harvard's fault, not OPs) is seriously getting in the way of communication since I went in to RTFA primed to find garbage.
- belovedeagle 11y agoHow is the headline clickbait? It's a true finding of the study. I would say that a headline leading with the 3% figure would be much more misleading, since the relevant figure for someone considering whether to receive medical treatment (for example) is the "1 in 2" figure. I don't care if the doctors only mess up 3% of my medication interactions; just one is bad enough.
- vpribish 11y agoI called it clickbaity for 2 reasons : 1) The buzzfeed style (gotta have some digits!) didn't help because any reasonable person would have said "half". 2) While 1:2 is technically true it's also the scariest number they could choose and is useless out of context. the level of fear and outrage goes down upon reading the article. also, it really does matter how many erroneous medication interactions you have - not just operations-with-at-least-one. Most of the errors did not have dire consequences (there were no fatalities in the study). Errors are bad, but it's not all errors are equal.
- dang 11y agoOk, we'll put "half" in the title. Seems pretty mild on the linkbait spectrum, but still, that's a good edit.
- medymed 11y agoI will be looking for frequency of medication errors per medication. Giving someone a triple dose of advil or local anesthetic probably not too big of a deal, but a triple dose of phenylephrine or labetolol is asking for trouble. In other words, I'm curious of the rate of scary mistakes versus meh-don't-worry-about-it mistakes, though that terminology is not politically acceptable. Explaining any difference there would be fascinating.
- nommm-nommm 11y agoIs this bit from the article what you are looking for? Of all the observed adverse drug events and medication errors that could have resulted in patient harm — four of which were intercepted by operating room staff before affecting the patient — 30 percent were considered significant, 69 percent serious, and less than 2 percent life-threatening; none were fatal.
- idiot900 11y ago"Scary" really depends on the clinical situation. It's much more difficult to define clearly than it seems. Too much NSAID or local anesthetic is usually worse than too much of a short acting, easily countered drug like phenylephrine or labetalol.
- backtoyoujim 11y agoNow that is an industry ripe for disruption.
- shanemhansen 11y agoMy mom was recovering from surgery a few years back. She was in lots of pain. I should mention that it was hard getting the time of day from doctors or nurses about next steps (how did the surgery go, how long would we be at the hospital, etc). My mom gradually got quieter and went to sleep. I little while later they came in and took her to the ICU. Turns out they had accidentally overdosed her on narcotics and depressed her respiration to unacceptable levels. The nurses and doctors were quite friendly for a couple hours after that. It turns out that after a nurse almost kills a loved one you a small window of decent service from hospital staff. I have family members who have collectively lost years of their lives due to bad medications and negligence, but they a) aren't the kind of people who sue b) don't have the resources or willpower to do so even if they wanted to.
- steveeq1 11y agoI don't get it, don't lawyers work for percentage? Any lawyer would take that case as you described.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoMaybe they didn't want to sue - maybe they believed it was just an accident (shit happens), and without direct consequences to day-to-day life, they felt suing a hospital (and taking money & time out of system that generally helps people) is kind of an assole thing to do? I know I would feel like that even if I got almost killed by hospital staff, but eventually recovered to full physical and mental capacity (if I ended up somehow disabled or permanently ill, then it would be another story).
- steveeq1 11y agoThen they would choose not to sue as a matter of principle, not because they didn't not have the resources. Not denying what you are describing as good reasons, I'm just saying that listing "a lack of resources" a reason one can't sue in the United States is false.
- 11y ago
- codingdave 11y agoAs a patient, whether or not to have surgery is a tough decision. Surgery really sucks. Even if everything goes as expected, they are cutting you up, and putting you under drugs that mess with you so badly that you don't notice them cutting you up. You spend at least a few days, if not weeks, recovering, usually involving more drugs which come with side effects and addiction risk. And that is when it goes right. There are always small percentages thrown at you of the chance of possible complications, so a 3% risk of a drug problem is another one to add to the list. Even if there is a much higher chance of something going "wrong" during the procedure, we're talking about a scenario where I am already trusting my medical team to handle my body, deal with what happens, and bring me back to the recovery room . So an "Oops, oh crap, better fix this." moment is not shocking to me... I just assume it happens, and trust the doctors to react appropriately. But all of that risk and all of the problems with surgery ... you choose that to fix what is usually a worse problem. For example, I once got to make the decision to have a surgery that had a 97% chance of letting me walk again. And today, I am walking. Would it be great if there was a 0% chance of error? Of course! But I take it much more as an area in which we can improve, not a shocking metric that would scare me away from surgery.
- wilwade 11y agoAnd people wonder why I would prefer to have an IBM Watson powered robot treating me. (Actually I would prefer the doctor required to work in conjunction with Watson. So many simple errors would be caught).
- chazu 11y agoMedication errors and adverse drug events are a terrifyingly common cause of hospitalization and even death, especially in the elderly. Thankfully some companies are really doing neat things to try and improve the quality of care that elders receive. For example Carekinesis[1], one of my old employers, is effectively engineering solutions to help new-school eldercare paradigms - specifically PACE programs[2] - to decrease adverse drug events to nearly zero. If you haven't heard of PACE as an alternative model for elder care (as opposed to long term care) I highly recommend you learn about it. The statistics on its effectiveness versus LTC are astounding. [1] http://www.carekinesis.com http://www.carekinesis.com [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Program_of_All-Inclusive_Care_for_the_Elderly https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Program_of_All-Inclusive_Care_...
- TrevorJ 11y agoThere's a list of common medications I can't take because of a fairly benign condition I have, which is and has been in my medical records for years. 90% of the time doctors prescribe me things I can't take, even though the information is simple and at their fingertips. I can't imagine the number of mistakes that must get made in more complex cases.