4 ms·
Tiny 'ThumbSats' Aim to Bring Space to All
- waterlesscloud 11y agoInterested in hearing what sort of experiment would be worth doing with one of these (I'm genuinely clueless).
- cgriswald 11y agoOff the top of my slightly drunk and exhausted head: Hands-on education opportunities for students. A Dyson swarm could theoretically watch and record space in all directions all the time. We could (with great expense) build something like that in orbit around the Earth. These could be used as a proof-of-concept or to locate problem areas that are difficult to brainstorm on Earth. I'm sure there are some astroimaging applications, though without knowing the specs of the sats I'm not sure what they might be. My first thought was gathering data outside the atmosphere to correct images taken on Earth.
- adrianN 11y agoPut some magnetic field sensors in them and you can get a very accurate image of the Earth's magnetic field.
- vpribish 11y agothey quoted $20k (ballpark) per mission - that strikes me as a little high for 25g to LEO. What is that paying for? Using the old benchmark of $10k per lb to LEO 25g could cost $550. Cubesats weigh up to 1.3kg and cost about $100k to launch (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CubeSat#Costs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CubeSat#Costs) - so that works out to $2,000 for 25g. Is that extra $18k going to bespoke mission planning work or amortized development costs or really great t-shirts? This is very exciting, of course. I'm tickled by a non-game web-form having this label: "Select how many satellites you wish to launch"
- david_shaw 11y agoI keep reading about things like the Kessler Effect (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kessler_syndrome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kessler_syndrome) -- in fact, even here on HN. Wouldn't launching numerous micro-satellites into orbit significantly speed up the accumulation of space debris that will eventually be hazardous?
- vpribish 11y agoThese are meant for very low orbit where they re-enter within weeks. The biggest orbital debris problem is explosions leaving many thousands of struts spreading out over their own special orbits. I wonder which is better from a debris standpoint : the current mega-satellites or a swarm of micro-satellites (with much lower explosive potential, each). There could be a counter-intuitive result where smaller, simpler, less-energetic satellites could mitigate the orbital debris problem.
- cgriswald 11y agoIndividually, micro-sats will have much less momentum at the same speed. In the event of a collision, not all the mass of the micro-sats will necessarily impact the other object, either. By way of analogy, you would probably rather be shot with buckshot than a cannonball if you wanted an open casket.
- cgriswald 11y agoIt might be simpler to think of these "numerous micro-satellites" as a single, larger satellite. They'll share the same orbit and speed. But they will, in my opinion, be less likely to cause a cascade. Any object they impact will likely be left intact and have less energy transfered to it than if the micro-sats were a single solitary object with the same mass. To answer your question: no. As the sibling poster and the article mentions, these micro-sats will only be in orbit for a few weeks. So there is no accumulation. The solution to space debris right now is avoidance for existing sats and decaying orbits for future satellites such as these.
- Rebelgecko 11y agoFor some context, there are already tens of thousands of pieces 5cm and up of debris, so a few hundred cubesats a year won't (immediately) make a huge difference. Cubesats are supposed to be able to put themselves into orbits that won't last more than 25 years, although not everyone has followed the guidelines. But, there are a lot of cool solutions out there for deorbiting Cubesats, even for ones without propulsion. There's a few ways you can increase drag when your mission is over, like having wings that'll create more drag when oriented a certain way, or sending out a big balloon. A more sci-fi sounding method is to use an electromagnetic tether
- david-given 11y agoSee also Pocket Spacecraft: http://pocketspacecraft.com/ http://pocketspacecraft.com/ These are mylar disks about the size of a CD with circuitry and solar panels printed directly onto them, with a metal stiffening wire around the edge that doubles as the antenna. They're planning on launching hundreds via a three-unit cubesat mothership. Last year they ran a Kickstarter to try and get a swarm of these into lunar orbit; they didn't make their goal, but they're going ahead anyway. They mass substantially less than a gram each! They're so light they reckon that they'll survive reentry into Earth's atmosphere; if you buy one, you get your name and address printed on it so that if someone finds it they can post it back to you...
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoCubesats can have sensors, radios, propulsion. I'm wondering why this all doesn't scale down to thumbsats. Particularly propultion. Only very tiny impulse is needed to move very tiny mass. Why not a thumbsat Mars mission?