5 ms·
As someone with a kid in a charter school (Success Academy) I have to disagree with the very premise for how you discuss them. Some charter schools is a respon
by ThomPete 11y ago
As someone with a kid in a charter school (Success Academy) I have to disagree with the very premise for how you discuss them.
Some charter schools is a response to the problem of amongst other issues, a way too strong teachers union and it's inability to develop contemporary learning environments for children. In California teachers union have in their agreement that they can't get replaced by new technology.
The high salaries is a tradeoff from the high pressure they put on the teachers and the very fact that they can get fired.
My son start 7.30 in the morning and ends 4.30 in the afternoon you can guess how much the teachers work. They are 32 children in each class.
Success Academy started in Harlem and was responsible for taking the kids out of their social fragile environments and starting to give them good habits and start showing that that others expected things from them and believed in them to deliver. Success Academy is one of the best performing schools in NY state.
Compared to the usual public school system, charter schools when done right is an amazing alternative to the public system.
Now I don't believe charter schools are the only way to do things, but I do believe that teachers unions are way to strong and until they start to change I will do what I can to keep my kids out of them.
Success Academy is privately run but publicly funded and the school have to fight for every dime they get while still staying out of the control of the teachers unions influence through the DOE.
So it's a much more complex discussion than the one you paint here. If anything when charterschools are done right they are a much better model for how the public school system should work IMO.
- galby 11y agoThat may be true for Success Academy but there are some truly awful charters out there. The problem is that what it means to be a charter school varies so much from state to state and even from district to district.
- ThomPete 11y agoThere are even more truly awful publicly funded schools out there too. Harlem have their share. That doesn't mean there aren't good public schools too. But that's not a way to discuss this IMO. Teaching is hard, getting a school to run properly is hard in todays environment. Charterschools are good because they allow for differentiation in education. We don't want anyone to be educated exactly the same way. Thats not a good thing. That charterschools allow for people to take advantage of them is another discussion and can be solved in many different ways. Instead of just critiquing the fact that they can be misused perhaps it would be more constructive to discuss how to make sure snake oil salesmen doesn't take advantage of the system. Just like we do with other businesses in general.
- dalke 11y agoI feel like you are presenting a fake contrast. When I was in public schools, there was a lot of differentiation in education, and students definitely weren't taught all the same, including different levels (eg, AP vs. non AP history), different tracks (eg, extra courses for those interested in practical arts, or interested in programming, for a career), and special support for students with more specific needs, including in my case speech therapy. Nor do I get the sense that my school system was special in that regard. "getting a school to run properly is hard in todays environment" When was it ever easy to run properly?
- ThomPete 11y agoNo fake contrast. I am responding to the OP who seem to want charter schools to go away based on a claim that they are somehow bad. Success Academy was started because the public school system failed to educate kids in Harlem. The philosophy have since then been copied at other schools with success my son is in Williamsburg. This isn't only about the curriculum but about the very approach to teaching the kids AND the parents involvement in their kids education. The difference between today and back then I feel is best illustrated by this http://i.imgur.com/LglSapk.jpg http://i.imgur.com/LglSapk.jpg Success Academy fights this with tooth and nail but in return require quite a lot from their teachers. It's not a perfect system but I prefer it compared to the public school he first went to exactly because its focus on getting parents back on the side of the teacher and their goal and method for getting the kids to love learning.
- dalke 11y agoWhich OP is that? You responded to comments from two accounts, which said: galby: "there are some truly awful charters out there" exelius: "To be fair, not all charter schools are for-profit, and there are good charter schools and bad ones. But the entire system stinks; it cuts funding to struggling districts, leaving them in a perpetual budget crisis." Neither say charter schools are categorically bad. Exelius's point is that the funding system to support charter schools is what stinks. Your illustration has no historical basis. You are viewing history through rose-colored glasses. I'll demonstrate with a classic, the 1955 book "Why Johnny Can't Read: And What You Can Do about It". This placed the blame on teachers and the school pedagogy for poor childhood literacy rates, not the students. Parents reacted to that by pushing for policy changes. That book reverberated for decades. At https://news.google.com/newspapers?id=qtZQAAAAIBAJ&sjid=ORMEAAAAIBAJ&pg=2065%2C1980872 https://news.google.com/newspapers?id=qtZQAAAAIBAJ&sjid=ORME... you can see: > Since then, other arguments [besides teachers 'simply using the wrong techniques'] have cropped up. Those who sympathize with teachers blame overly-defensive administrations and boards of education. Still others say parents are responsible for having abdicated social duties to the schools, transforming them from educational institutions into huge day care centers. Sound like a familiar discussion? Here's an example of a letter to the editor from 1976, https://news.google.com/newspapers?id=VdYeAAAAIBAJ&sjid=nVYEAAAAIBAJ&pg=6890%2C3120348 https://news.google.com/newspapers?id=VdYeAAAAIBAJ&sjid=nVYE... , where a teacher places the blame on school boards for not letting the teachers apply real discipline to the "hoodlums" who get to pass because of "social promotions." This teacher doesn't think the students are getting any discipline from their parents over poor grades. This Ann Landers humor piece from 1984 reflects the idea that the students are doing poorly because the parents don't care; both parent and child veg in front of the TV: https://news.google.com/newspapers?id=zbUfAAAAIBAJ&sjid=htcEAAAAIBAJ&pg=5781%2C297333 https://news.google.com/newspapers?id=zbUfAAAAIBAJ&sjid=htcE... My comment here is surely no strong proof, only suggestive that you may need to research the history which brought us movies like "Blackboard Jungle".
- JediWing 11y ago> Some charter schools is a response to the problem of amongst other issues, a way too strong teachers union and it's inability to develop contemporary learning environments for children. --------------------------- What are some things that Charter schools allow teachers to do (to develop a contemporary learning environment) that teachers' unions prevent in public schools? (and not other factors like budget constraints, etc.)
- ThomPete 11y agoOne of the primary things is they allow them to get fired to avoid lemon teachers. http://www.economist.com/news/united-states/21599005-reformers-want-make-it-easier-sack-bad-teachers-dance-lemons http://www.economist.com/news/united-states/21599005-reforme... In California the teachers union even have a clause that prevents their teachers from getting fired because of technological advance in the class room.
- exelius 11y agoRight; I don't think all charter schools are bad. But the way the system is implemented in many states, there is no way to know what the quality of a school actually is. The way it's funded causes a disproportionate drop in available resources for students who aren't in charter schools, which stresses an already broken system to a level that endangers students safety. Private schools are and have always been an option if you don't like the level of education provided by your local district. If we feel we're not getting our money's worth from our public schools, that's fine -- but fix the public schools, don't divert the money elsewhere. Schools don't react to competitive pressures, so all that causing competition for state funding is going to do is decrease quality.
- ThomPete 11y agoI don't buy the premise that they are somehow stressing an already broken system. Again 32 to students in every class. We aren't talking about small classes here we aren't talking luxurious schools. And then on top of that the positive influence it has one socially challenged areas. There is a world of difference between a public school in Tribecca and one in Harlem. To be able to attend the one in Tribecca you need to live in Tribecca, you have to be zoned. Success Academy have a lottery which means kids from harlem, bronx, tribecca, williamsburg all will attend the same school regardless of where they live. What you are claiming about charter schools are many many times worse in public school system where you get a lot of lousy education and very strong teachers unions on top of it.
- exelius 11y agoLet's say a public school has grades K-5 with 2 classrooms of 32 students per grade. That's 12 classrooms, for a total of 384 students. Let's also assume that school gets $6000 per year, per student (total of $2.3 million). The budget is already threadbare, so there aren't many places left to cut. Now let's say you take away 10% of the students from that school, such that you now have 29 students in each class. The school's budget is now $2 million, but they haven't shed any costs: they still have the same number of teachers, the same buildings to maintain, etc. So they have to get creative with their budget, which is how you end up with crappy local schools that don't have arts classes, a school nurse, or enough books to go around. This causes more students to flee to the charter school system, making the problem worse and creating situations where kids are frequently unsupervised. Worse, these schools are often forced to take on students with no additional funding in the event a charter school goes bankrupt (which happens to 1-2 charter schools a year in most major cities). I'm sure my take on this issue would be different if I had kids, and the teacher's unions are part of the problem. But we should fix the unions and the schools, not provide an unregulated system where government money is funneled into private businesses with little to no oversight.
- bko 11y agoI think the real benefit of charter schools is consumer choice. You get to chose what school to send your children to. It's a very personal choice as to what you teach your children and how you raise them. Forcing children into one school due to the accident of geography is an injustice that unfortunately mostly impacts the most marginal people in society.
- kraig911 11y agoThe issue is quality of education is not easily quantified and measurable beyond testing. People want to see their tax dollars working but then you have now a system in place to protect both the teachers, the schools, and the tax payers but NOT the actual students. I've helped a few Charter Schools and religious ones, and while the kids are mostly behaved everyone I've been too they are way behind track academically. I think the actual lack of oversight creates a different problem.