4 ms·
Agreed. 20 years, and I've never seen a return on an outsourced project. The overseas company whittles the specs down so far, your own guys could do it in a wee
by JoeAltmaier 11y ago
Agreed. 20 years, and I've never seen a return on an outsourced project. The overseas company whittles the specs down so far, your own guys could do it in a weekend. The cost of managing is larger than the value received: barriers include language, timezone, network access, culture, currency, import/export rules. The culture one is huge. Many cultures, a worker won't contradict a boss for any reason. So you're trying to get an expert opinion out of them about how to proceed, they're just saying "Uh huh, yes boss".
- cubancigar11 11y agoFunny. In my experience telling something as it is is a very easy way to piss of the client, who in general have huge ego that they are from a superior culture.
- cookiecaper 11y agoOne of the primary benefits of an external contractor is that they are mostly unaffected by whatever politics are occurring within the company. This means that they're more likely to give direct, honest feedback, and they won't worry very much about whose feelings it hurts. This is supremely valuable in most organizations, and impossible for most employees to provide if they want to stick around for more than a few months. There are unreasonable people everywhere, of course, so it's not that weird to find a client who doesn't understand the value of this service.
- thothamon 11y agoEven if that is true (which it may well be), it's yet another landmine for companies who seek solutions via outsourcing. I'd agree with OP on this. I've never seen a distributed, outsourced approach work. The product has always been poor or even worthless. Having said that, I have seen distributed, in-house projects work, sometimes very well, even when the teams were internationally distributed, and even with moderate language barriers.
- MortenK 11y agoYou should try other outsourcing destinations. Large timezone differences are indeed a hurdle, and culture differences is always underestimated. Add to that the general ineptitude of managing projects in large companies, and you have a recipe for disaster. In Western Europe, the most compatible culture and therefore easiest place to start, is Eastern Europe and Russia. If you are in the US, I'd personally just outsource to US companies in the midwest. Some of my western European clients are actually doing this now, as for example NC hourly rates are lower than Moscow rates. Managing projects where you have big cultural differences require many years of experience in that particular area. Even then, it requires a much higher project management effort. If management of a project with a local team take on average 10% of total project time, a project with developers in a markedly different work culture will easily take 20-30% of time spend.
- IndianAstronaut 11y agoThe cost of living in most Indian cities is higher than the midwest. Good devs there will cost quite a bit.
- josephjrobison 11y agoNever heard of that before - what's some good data to read more about that?
- Scuds 11y agohttps://www.expatistan.com/cost-of-living/comparison/st-louis/mumbai https://www.expatistan.com/cost-of-living/comparison/st-loui... Eh... I dunno how accurate this is.
- IndianAstronaut 11y agoYou can look up prices on some Indian real estate sites such as olx.in. Try and focus on tech areas, not some random parts of cities.
- JoeAltmaier 11y ago
- VOYD 11y agoAnd now the bigger software companies are opening "research centers" in the offshore countries and just plain moving the jobs there. Specifically China, which was the big deal when the president of China recently met with Facebook, Twitter, Google, and Apple at Microsoft's main campus.
- mtberatwork 11y ago> And now the bigger software companies are opening "research centers" in the offshore countries and just plain moving the jobs there. Unfortunately, that's been going on for a while now with the big consulting agencies.
- artpar 11y agoI guess that was the Indian Prime Minister. It could be both though.
- HillRat 11y agoOr they will require such detailed functional specs that by the end you're almost literally just paying for ten fingers to do the typing. An example that I wish weren't true: one specification had detail to the level of specifying that a particular form required a button to submit the form. The returned product had a button titled "Submit the Form." It did nothing, because the specification did not explicitly say to submit the form when the button was clicked.
- dmux 11y agoThis is gold.
- sopooneo 11y agoA web app I inherited, for which I do not have the original spec, and initially developed by an outsourced offshore team, had one route that was literally "/obscure/reset_password?user_id=x". A light dawned when I realized they must have been asked to provide an unguessable or "obscure" endpoint for account actions.