8 ms·
I think it's part of a general trend of language designers (and even language fans) not understanding what makes languages work in practice. For academic langua
by pron 11y ago
I think it's part of a general trend of language designers (and even language fans) not understanding what makes languages work in practice. For academic languages this may not matter, but if you actually want your language to be used, you need to pay attention. A recent study[1] has shown that "extrinsic" factors (performance, tooling, familiarity, libraries) matter a lot more than intrinsic factors (syntax, abstractions) when it comes to adopting programming languages. A language that understood this beautifully was Java[2] (and, I believe, Go, which is very much in the spirit of the Java philosophy), that analyzed existing "advanced" languages like Scheme, Self and Modula (and indeed some of the people involved with those languages were among Java's early designers) and realized that the features that give those languages most bang-for-the-buck weren't clever abstractions but extra-linguistic features such as GC, dynamic linking and JITs[3], that can be packaged in a crude, "blue-collar" language that's familiar (and familiarity is indeed among the top factors in choosing a language, while "correctness" -- as in more powerful type system -- and particular language features are among the last). James Gosling called it a wolf in sheep's clothing. A wolf in wolf's clothing may look more fierce, and the sheep's clothing may indeed limit its maneuverability a bit, but it can still be almost as wolfish, yet much more palatable.
OTOH, Kotlin took whatever it could from Ceylon (the nullability types, flow-sensitive typing) while keeping 100% seamless interoperability with Java as the top priority, so it may not be a revolution, but its adoption costs are virtually zero. It doesn't even have much of a runtime library; it was designed in such a way that all cool features could be applied to Java's standard library. The idea was that abstractions are great as long as they don't come at the expense of more important features, such as availability of libraries, tools etc (Kotlin even supports Java's annotation processors, so popular libraries that rely on compile-time verification/code-generation such as Dagger can work on Kotlin code).
Of course, I take this much further than you and believe, unlike you, that the contribution of advanced language-level abstractions is not so pronounced at all (or, at least, it hasn't been shown to be significant), and obviously I have a very different perspective on Scala than you, but at least we can agree on something :)
[1]: Paper: http://lmeyerov.github.io/projects/socioplt/papers/oopsla2013.pdf http://lmeyerov.github.io/projects/socioplt/papers/oopsla201... Accompanying talk: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v2ITaI4y7_0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v2ITaI4y7_0
[2]: https://youtu.be/Dq2WQuWVrgQ?t=14m12s https://youtu.be/Dq2WQuWVrgQ?t=14m12s about why Java was designed the way it was
[3]: Sun had experimented with a JIT for Self long before it was introduced to Java, and the plan was to make Java exploit JITs almost from the get-go.
- vvanders 11y agoYeah, the Kotlin inter-op is really well done. Having IntelliJ just work is always discounted more than I think people should. I do wish Kotlin had more pattern matching semantics but that's just me being picky, it's a really nice language.
- logicchains 11y ago>Having IntelliJ just work is always discounted more than I think people should. To be fair, Kotlin has the advantage of being created by the company that makes IntelliJ, so it's got a big head start IDE-wise.
- aembleton 11y agoYes, and that is really important when it comes to language use. The more people who use the language, the more it can develop and the more libraries that can be built for it. The other advantage of Kotlin is that it builds on top of the existing Java code base. Java has had decades to build up an ecosystem of frameworks and libraries. Kotlin builds on these with excellent interop.
- mike_hearn 11y agoI like Kotlin too but in fairness this is a Ceylon thread ;) From what I can see, Ceylon has a blend of strengths that should make it appeal to a certain segment of the market. On one hand, it's a fresh start and has a lot of the cleanness and terseness that I like from Kotlin. On the other, Gavin is clearly very much into type systems and type theory, and Ceylon has a more complex/powerful type system than Kotlin does. I'll admit that I'm not totally sure whether the additional complexity is worth it, but I'm very open to being persuaded. So it seems to me like Ceylon should appeal to people who currently like Scala or Haskell and push the type systems to the limit, but really want something without historical baggage like XML literals and other oddities. And I'm sure there are plenty of programmers like that. The real question will be interop costs. Kotlin doesn't have any and that's the main reason people can consider it in existing projects, or introduction inside large corporations. Ceylon takes a more Scala-like approach where it has its own standard library, its own collections, etc.