5 ms·
> I love CC, but CC-BY-NC-ND is VERY different from CC-BY. Both OA? Maybe, under a fairly narrow definition of access; CC-BY-NC-ND is just fine, and it seems e
by jacobolus 11y ago
> I love CC, but CC-BY-NC-ND is VERY different from CC-BY. Both OA? Maybe, under a fairly narrow definition of access;
CC-BY-NC-ND is just fine, and it seems entirely reasonable to call it “open access”. By far the most important thing the public can do with scientific papers is read them.
Obviously it can sometimes be nice to allow translations to other languages, interpretations in other media, bundling of collections of papers, reuse of the figures in other people’s works, copy/pasting the text into Wikipedia, or whatever.
But if folks need to get separate dispensation from the author/publisher for such additional uses, I have no problem with that.
- IanCal 11y agoIt does meet the most basic requirement of being free to read. That's a huge improvement. I've no problem with BY, but NC and ND are quite restrictive. ND particularly as the license says I can't "build upon" the material. What does that mean in a scientific paper, I can't replicate your experiment? I can't create improvements to your algorithm and publish a new paper?
- Amorymeltzer 11y agoIt's not that bad. Copyright covers the publication, in this case the written paper, not the technique; that could be covered by a patent, but is unlikely. For basic, wet-lab bench research, traditional copyright has for example permitted replication forever - no issue there. Code is a trickier issue, but generally no, you could not publish derivative code. Not that you generally can under traditional copyright.