3 ms·
It's strange to see Apple pushing so hard to reduce storage requirements, while at the same time charging $50 for an extra 32GB of flash on the AppleTV (and cha
by mikeash 11y ago
It's strange to see Apple pushing so hard to reduce storage requirements, while at the same time charging $50 for an extra 32GB of flash on the AppleTV (and charging $100 for an extra 48GB on the iPhone).
The emphasis on storage seems to indicate that they see storage limitations as a user experience problem. But if they'd stop gouging on storage upgrades, that would improve the user experience immensely, especially if they bumped up the storage on the bottom-end iPhone. In the other direction, the fact that they do gouge seems to indicate that they see storage limitations as a profit opportunity, so it's weird that they're trying to make it less important.
Maybe this is just the result of internal conflicts. Hardware doesn't want to upgrade storage, so software tries to mitigate that.
- s73v3r 11y agoReducing storage requirements means that one can fit more apps on the device, and that apps download and can be used faster.
- mikeash 11y agoNot charging outrageous prices for upgrades, and not shipping devices with ridiculously small storage, would also mean that one can fit more apps on the device. So what I'm wondering is why they're doing one but not the other.
- s73v3r 11y agoI really do not care about the upgrade costs. However, doing the reduction in assets means that people using their devices in places where speeds are not great also get a benefit.
- mikeash 11y agoI don't know how well that works. Your apps will be ready faster, but if they're streaming content on the fly then you'll need a relatively fast connection to avoid lots of delays while using it. With a more traditional system where you download everything up front, it will take longer but once you have it your speeds don't matter.
- ssmoot 11y agoI have a PS4. Don't play very often. But one thing you notice real quick is sloppy packaging. The Binding of Isaac needs more than 200MB? Isn't it a handful of sprites and procedural levels? I've only played for... I dunno, 30 minutes, but it seems like it could have easily been a PS2 game. And then you have games with 300MB save files. Which is a huge problem since you only get 1GB of cloud storage for saves. So you end up deleting most. I care about efficiency. I like that my iPhone charges in 45 minutes unlike the multi hour charges of the ~3,000+mAh devices I've owned. I like small downloads. The Apple TV isn't going to have the power of a dedicated console. There's no reason to download 40GB of texture data.
- mikeash 11y agoI agree with what you're saying overall. But this new policy from Apple doesn't seem to be encouraging efficiency. In some ways it encourages wastefulness, because once you do the work of making your assets load on demand, and as long as your stuff fits into 20GB, you don't really have to care how large they are. They'll always fit on the user's device, you don't have to worry about crowding out other apps or causing the user to receive annoying alerts about storage being full, etc., it's all just managed for you. It will be painful for people on slow connections, and expensive for people on metered connections, but getting developers to care about that is probably challenging.