5 ms·
Is anyone but me conflicted about the idea of Google being involved in "identifying who is at highest risk and developing interventions that preempt psychosis",
by mcguire 11y ago
Is anyone but me conflicted about the idea of Google being involved in "identifying who is at highest risk and developing interventions that preempt psychosis", given that Google's primary product is detailed personal information about everyone?
- witty_username 11y agoWell, we don't know how it will tie into personal information; let's not speculate at this early stage.
- shas3 11y agoUnder FDA or American Psychiatric Association guidance and regulations, it could be a suitable aid for help in diagnosing mental health issues. Yet, it would only be ethically reasonable for it to be nothing more than a diagnostic tool in the hands of qualified psychiatrists much like an MRI/CT/PET/etc. is for a radiologist or neurologist or ECG/ultrasound/etc. for a cardiologist. Edit: In my experience, experts in some areas are just slow to adopt technology. Physicians and cardiologists still use rubber-tube stethoscopes (there's a startup in this area, Eko Devices that's trying to change it, but the physician community, IMO has inertia). Sleep health assessment is done manually by technicians. Psychiatrists rely on simple questionnaires (or sets of questions), while leaving out plenty of other data points. Same with doctors in many other fields, quantification of behavior/phenotype/etc. is in its infancy, with only numbers like blood glucose, blood pressure, body temperature, etc. being reliably used.
- subnaught 11y agoSerious question: what's wrong with a rubber-tube stethoscope?
- shas3 11y agoI don't think anything is wrong, per se. But the notion that in 2015, we don't have more widely used fancier technology on stethoscopes is interesting. There are some problems in how stethoscopes are used, primarily because a lot of skill is required to interpret the sounds and many doctors could be and actually are poor at this. There are many studies which show this, for example [1]. [1] http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/105/6/1184.short http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/105/6/1184.sho...
- theoh 11y agoThe idea that 2015 should be about "fancy" technology sounds like it was invented by advertising people. Fancy in the way multi-blade disposable razors are fancy? No thanks.
- mfoy_ 11y agoTwo opportunities to plug PSYCHO-PASS in one day? We're on a roll, HN! But seriously, if Google co-opted people's smart phone data to do covert psychological evaluations on a constant basis we'd literally be one step removed from the dystopic future PSYCHO-PASS depicted. Albeit a big step (sending out armed teams to apprehend at-risk subjects before they have a chance to hurt themselves or others).
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago>Albeit a big step (sending out armed teams to apprehend at-risk subjects before they have a chance to hurt themselves or others). Look at the story behind the police officer who was committed for trying to expose police quotas. Is that not the same as an armed team coming to commit you... just for an even less justifiable reason?
- pc2g4d 11y agoDo you have a link for this?
- stuxnet79 11y agoExcept we have a choice to not fall into the Google trap and altogether avoid using any Google products. Also my hue isn't cloudy at all ;) > sending out armed teams to apprehend at-risk subjects Even if we did reach a point where we could be able to identify at-risk subjects with high accuracy this would be very difficult to bring about, just because of the implications.
- mfoy_ 11y agoRight, hence the big step is for a government agency to receive a mandate to implement such a system. The even bigger step is probably to openly make enforcement decisions based on that info. I think there is a huge gap between "your psychological data indicates you may be at increased risk of committing a violent crime" and actually taking people off the streets based on that indicator. But then again, with what we've learned since Snowden, this doesn't actually seem that impossible...
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoNot at all conflicted. I am 100% sure I do not like the direction this is going. From people who see mental health as a moral failing to those who see it as a justifiable reason to restrict rights; I see great potential for harm.
- DanBC 11y agoOf all the human rights stuff happening around psychosis an early diagnosis doesn't seem too bad. It's a bit of a worry, but it's not as bad as being shot and killed[1]; transported to hospital by police against your will; being medicated (sometimes by force) against your will (with meds that will shorten your life); being deprived of your liberty (in more ways than just being held in a hospital); etc etc. [1] http://tacreports.org/storage/documents/2013-justifiable-homicides.pdf http://tacreports.org/storage/documents/2013-justifiable-hom...
- hackuser 11y agoAs the former NIH mental health head is quoted in the article: One of the possibilities here is, by using the technologies we already have, technologies that are linked to a cellphone, technologies that are linked to the Internet, we may be able to get much more information about behavior than what we’ve been able to use in making a diagnosis He also makes arguments for more involuntary treatment. Some ideas like this are already in practice. Some police departments, such as Chicago's, try to predict likely criminals and pre-emptively threaten and track them. Also, let's remember that the field of mental health gave us lobotomies, torture, and other abuses. I fear society does nothing until there's a catastrophe, and only then reacts.
- baconner 11y agoSomething that I feel does not get enough attention wrt using machine learning is proper consideration of the downsides when there are false positives. There are always false positives and you have to weigh the harm of a false positive against the benefits you think you'll get. On one end of the spectrum a false positive serves you an ad you'd never be interested in. On the other end it gets you killed. Searching for the mentally ill in this way could lean hard toward the latter. Scary stuff if misused.
- baconner 11y agoI'd also add that the big problem in mental health treatment in the US is not identifying people with mental illness. The big problem is that we're not equipped (funded or institutionally prepared) to treat the huge number of people who we already know need it. So seeking out the mentally ill isn't really the big problem either. We should imo be more focused on solving the big issues like stopping using prisons in lieu of real mental health facilities, etc.
- peter303 11y agoI think Sergey was a bit terrified of developing Parkinsons, a possiblity from his genetic profile. So I guess this in part contributes to their attempt to build a general world class brain institute. Wno knows, technology could have amajor role in understanding and cure.
- Dirlewanger 11y agoAbsolutely. But by the time our inept government even gets around to considering regulations for...well, whatever that may entail, Google will already be heavily profiting off of whatever R&D they assembled years before. This is what our tax dollars give us. It's the government's fault they can't keep this guy on the payroll. On the whole, there's such mindbendingly little personal incentive to solve problems in the public sector when entities in the private sector will offer you whatever you desire in pay/benefits.
- petra 11y agoGoogle already takes into account searches that indicate mental health and sometimes shows related ads. Currently this is unregulated. Also in general Google is no worse(and probably much better) than current companies who sell mental health drugs who got fined for drugging children with risky drugs illegally , etc. So who knows, Maybe Google's involvement , and it's unique control structure(controlled by real people who seem to care, and not by the psychopathic being called "the corporation") would improve healthcare. Also ,some of this don't necessitates monitoring of search queries - for example there's some research about using EEG to monitor people with bipolar disorder - so maybe some of this monitoring could be done locally, in the name of privacy. But there are also ethical questions - for ex. if some social pressure could push someone who would suffer from mental health issues to getting treated and preventing far worse results in the future - what should we do ?
- pc2g4d 11y agoI'm definitely concerned about where this might head. Even the idea of early diagnosis is problematic as it carries with it all the baggage of mental health diagnostics---disorders defined by committee, lack of objectivity and reliability, lack of apparent physical reality backing up many disorders. Much of what we call mental health diagnosis can actually be reinterpreted as institutionalized societal judgments of non-conforming behaviors. The fact that (in my personal experience and the experience of many others) "treatment" often directly inhibits recovery makes an enhanced diagnosis->treatment pipeline a frightening thing indeed.
- emmab 11y agoI would be ok with a feature that looked at any history I had chosen to enable and informed me and only me that it believed I may be at risk for some mental illness, and suggested how to get help. For example if you search for https://www.google.com/search?q=suicide https://www.google.com/search?q=suicide (or related queries) it informs you of a suicide hotline.