2 ms·
Japan's economy isn't actually in depression, it's merely not growing: GDP growth moves up and down around the zero mark since the popping of their massive asse
by mike_hearn 11y ago
Japan's economy isn't actually in depression, it's merely not growing: GDP growth moves up and down around the zero mark since the popping of their massive asset bubble. Some years their GDP grows a bit, other years it shrinks a bit. So they haven't been growing but they haven't been in depression either.
There's a simple explanation for that. The very best developed economies struggle in these times to grow even at 2%, with most managing more like 1%. Since the start of the 90's the UK, for example, has managed only 1%. That's not totally surprising: GDP growth is cumulative. Each year repeating a 2% growth gets harder and harder because you have to add even more than you did last year to sustain it in percentage terms.
But Japan is in no way the very best of economies. Instead it has an economy seriously constrained by multiple factors, like an almost total lack of immigration (no new ideas) and a job-for-life culture that makes it practically impossible to fire people. Read up on "banishment rooms" to see how extreme that can really get. When was the last time Japan had a brand new, breakout product that the world swooned over? Since Nintendo lost their mojo I'm struggling to think of any. It's very rare that I interact with any company from Japan or hear "I went to Japan on a business trip".
Japan's economic woes have multiple causes: I think a far simpler explanation than "zomg deflation" is that when even the best struggle to manage 1% compounding growth Japan has no chance.
- mc32 11y agoI dont think anyone credible would claim Japan is in a depression but rather it has experienced deflation and very weak growth. Or how do we explain parasite children? Immigration is one solution to their problem, but not _the_ solution if were looking at the domestic demand side. Immigrants don't magically bring innovation, unless you're talking about very educated immigrants which typically are a tiny fraction of any immigrant group. There are lots of immigrants to Turkey and Bahrain even Mexico (though net looks different due to their outflows) but, no, I think Japan's issues are structural. They have a perverse system of incentives which plough too much into useless infrastructure and also their workplace culture. That's not to say they aren't innovating, they continue to innovate, it's just that they have not adapted well to globalization, and internal consumption hasn't compensated for the slack. That said, in this liberal economic context of today, deflation is not a good thing. Or ask Japanese how they feel about their economy.
- mike_hearn 11y agoWell, the point is the deflation-is-dangerous theory says it must be avoided at all costs because it leads to a downward spiral that ends in depression. But Japan is a counter-example that shows this theory cannot be true. There's no One True Solution to Japan's problems. Skilled immigration can help, by bringing outside experience and ideas into the mix. Look at how many successful American companies were either founded or are now run by immigrants (e.g. Google, Microsoft). But Japan barely even has that. Your last sentences are a bit puzzling to me: you seem to agree that deflation has not led to depression and that Japan's economic issues are more structural than currency related. But then you just repeat the claim that deflation is not a good thing and point to Japan as an example! The way I see it is any sudden change in the money supply is bad news because business likes predictability. The ideal monetary policy therefore would in fact target price stability (0% inflation) or mild deflation (as progress should mean things get cheaper over time). But you can't just say "deflation is bad" and then point to one country as an example, given that this entire thread is about the counterexample of Switzerland!
- mc32 11y agoThe way I see it, it, yes, one day, when all economies' slack has become taut and we're near equilibrium in terms of pop at least, then, at that point neo liberal economics predicated on growth will have outlived it's usefulness and will no longer deliver what society needs economically. When we get there growth will cease to be essential. In the meantime, growth and thus inflation, will be indicators of robust economies. Pervasive automation population decline and resource constraints (environmental stewardship) will have effects in the future whereby growth will not be an expression. But Japan, at the moment, has a population in decline, a lousy job market, stagnant wages, graduates taking lousy offers, more temp workers (not their parents' job security) all things most people would typically want to avoid in their economies. See if you can sell Russia, China, Mexico or Indonesia on deflationary economics. Stability means no innovation. Likely prices didn't change much for a pair of shoes between the fifth and sixth centuries. Great price stability. Is that something to look forward to? Little in the way of innovation, manufacturing, technique, sourcing, etc?