3 ms·
If the price of everything increases 10% then the increased cost of living disproportionately affects the poor for the duration of time that it takes for the wa
by dnautics 11y ago
If the price of everything increases 10% then the increased cost of living disproportionately affects the poor for the duration of time that it takes for the wages to match the increase. Compared to this the amount of debt held is basically trifling.
For example, if you are poor and are spending 80% of your income on living expenses, and 10% increase in prices drops your margin of survival from 20% to 12%, which is a 40% hit. If you are wealthy and spending 20% of your income, then your margin goes from 80% to 78% which is a 5% hit. If you were in the 'poor' case, would you rather have the 10% devaluation of your debt or would you rather have a 40% hit to your livable margin?
The converse is true in a system of deflation. If you are spending 80% of your income on living expenses, a 10% DECREASE in prices increases your margin of survival from 20% to 28%, which is a 40% increase, which you would almost certainly take over a 10% increase in real value of your debt.
Moreover the notion that the rich are not in debt is rediculous. A lot of things that the rich are able to partake in more easily (e.g. playing shorts on the short markets, options trade, margin trading, all currency FX trading) are debt-based instruments, so basically having secular inflation helps the rich play with money in innumerable ways.
- AnimalMuppet 11y ago> If the price of everything increases 10% then the increased cost of living disproportionately affects the poor for the duration of time that it takes for the wages to match the increase. True. > Compared to this the amount of debt held is basically trifling. False. Let's say you're middle class. You have a house, for which you have a mortgage. You have a car loan. You have credit card debt. You have a steady income, but your debt consumes 40% of your income. Your (non-debt) living expenses consume another 55%. (Your example of the poor person understates your case. Poor people don't have 20% survival margins to start with, so the impact of inflation on the poor is worse than you said.) Now deflation happens. Your non-debt expenses drop 10%, and so does your salary. But your debt expenses don't drop at all. Now where are you? Labeling your previous income as 100%, your debt still takes 40%. Your non-debt living expenses now takes 55% * 90% = 49.5%. Your total expenses are now 89.5%, and your income is 90%. Your margin went from 5% to 0.5%. Now, in fairness, as a middle class person, you have much more room than the poor person does to cut your expenses before you hit the edge of survival. Never the less, this shows how bad deflation can be if you're in debt. (Note well, though: The deflation has to be sustained enough to affect your income. If prices drop but your income stays the same, deflation is wonderful even if you are in debt.)
- dnautics 11y agoUhm, why would your salary go down when there's deflation? It's not like your employer is actively tracking living expenses daily and adjusting your salary to match.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoNot daily, but yearly, certainly they are. Where do you think they get the cost-of-living adjustment numbers from?