3 ms·
American military planners don't seem to agree with that, since they revised it later on to add options. It looks more likely that the original all-or-nothing S
by mikeash 11y ago
American military planners don't seem to agree with that, since they revised it later on to add options. It looks more likely that the original all-or-nothing SIOP was just an organizational thing due to limited planning resources available. To make a bad and inadequate analogy, it's like writing a computer program that does a bunch of unnecessary work because it's easier and you want to get it out the door. Except instead of wasted CPU cycles, it's millions of lives.
- scrumper 11y agoI think this is exactly the case. I do remember reading that early versions of SIOP were designed to be easily triggered by a heavily compromised administration after an attack, so there wasn't any real room for options which would require a more complicated and confusing command protocol than just saying, "go". Command and Control (I think) touches on the back-and-forth evolution with SIOP between the various branches of military and civilian leadership.