3 ms·
Ugh, I agree with the sentiment, but the proposed solution is almost as awkward as the prose he descries. I agree with Paul that "fancy", "formal" prose like th
by munificent 11y ago
Ugh, I agree with the sentiment, but the proposed solution is almost as awkward as the prose he descries. I agree with Paul that "fancy", "formal" prose like this is (randomly chosen example) does no one any favors:
> This work aims to address the disconnect between object-oriented design
> and implementation by rethinking the way object-oriented languages are
> structured. We have developed a set of requirements with which to identify
> good relationship models, and used these requirements to develop a
> new model for the object-oriented paradigm which focuses on relationships
> rather than objects. We will test the effectiveness of the model by designing
> a language which uses it, along with a formal specification and a
> practical implementation for the language. We will measure the effectiveness
> of our model by conducting case studies comparing development in
> existing languages with development in our relationship-based language.
But saying that the only solution is to write how you speak informally to friends also eliminates prose like:
> The tide climbs. The moon hangs small and yellow and gibbous. On the rooftops
> of beachfront hotels to the east, and in the gardens behind them, a half-dozen
> American artillery units drop incendiary rounds into the mouths of mortars.
I don't think Anthony Doerr uses phrases like "mouths of mortars" when having beer with his friends, but his prose is an absolute work of art. Every single word and dollop of punctuation there is perfect.
The key part is not to write like you are speaking to your friends. It's to write like you are speaking to a specific audience. Have a picture in your mind of yourself speaking in a venue to one or more people. The image you have will dramatically affect the way you right.
Picture yourself giving a hollering a rousing speech to a platoon of soldiers about to enter into battle and your reader will hear the Battle Hymn of the Republic by the time they reach the end of your paragraph. Whisper your words into the ear of a lover and your reader will get the shivers.
For most of the writing we on HN do, sure, "explaining something cool to your friends over lunch" is exactly the right image to get your style in line. But it's a massive over-simplification to say all prose should be written with tat venue in mind.
Personally, I think "mercurial Spaniard" is a great description of Picasso.