7 ms·
The Story of Surface Book
- m52go 11y ago> how to set a vision long enough that a $900 million writedown doesn’t break you Goodness. That probably means there was much more than 9 figures of losses in total. The trust MSFT places in Panay and his team must be gargantuan. I really wonder what MSFT's upper-limit of tolerable losses was for the Surface program.
- qzcx 11y agoIf I remember correctly, the XBox was operating at a loss at the beginning. I think it was more than expected that it would take a few years to break into the market.
- ucaetano 11y agoThere's a major difference between operating at a loss while selling 1.3 million units in 3 months (more than the PS2, PS3, Wii) as the XBOX did and having a product that absolutely nobody is buying as the Surface.
- randomhunt 11y agoI travel on a train for a medium length journey 2-4 times a week. In the last 12 months I've noticed that the transition from never seeing a Surface (Pro) to seeing 5-10% of tablets being a Surface (Pro). The vast majority are iPads still but its interesting that Surface has made such inroads. Based on what I see the main reason is the combination of the keyboard and Outlook.
- Someone1234 11y agoI'd also tack on: It is about enterprise appeal. A lot of people forget that IT departments in medium to large companies need to be able to remotely manage equipment, Macs are "annoying" and iPads are damn near un-manage-able. So while a lot of middle managers outside of IT think that iPads are "cool" and push for them, they get a lot of push back from IT due to their impracticality and the amount of time/resources it would take to manage. A Surface Pro has none of these issues. It is a standard Windows 10 PC which can be managed via System Center/AD/GPO/etc, so they're non-effort machines for enterprise/IT. So that, I suspect, is why you're seeing so many so quickly. Internally non-IT management wants a "tablet" and the IT department is deflecting from iPads onto Surface Pros because it is in their best interests to do so.
- djloche 11y agoThere's a major difference between "a product that absolutely nobody is buying" and the revenue reported in the eight most recent quarters: $672MM (Q1-2016), $888MM (Q4-2015), $713MM (Q3-2015), $1100MM (Q2-2015), $908MM (Q1-2015), $409MM (Q4-2014), $500MM (Q3-2014), $893MM (Q2-2014). (to note, Q2 is their oct-nov-dec quarter) ~$6Billion in revenue means absolutely someone is buying Surface products.
- ucaetano 11y agoQ1-2016? Are you from the future? And for comparison, the original XBox sold $300M. In the first 3 weeks.
- djloche 11y agohttps://www.microsoft.com/investor/EarningsAndFinancials/Earnings/PressReleaseAndWebcast/FY16/Q1/default.aspx https://www.microsoft.com/investor/EarningsAndFinancials/Ear... In case you weren't aware, Microsoft released their 2016-Q1 earnings recently.
- ucaetano 11y agoGood point, I should have paid more attention to the dates, not just the numbers :)
- gamblor956 11y agoThe year (2016) refers to the calendar year in which Microsoft's fiscal year ends (Jun 2016). Many, but not all, companies use a standard fiscal year of Jul-Jun rather than a calendar year of Jan-Dec for financial reporting and tax purposes. Thus, Q1 2016 means the quarter ending Sep 30, 2015, for Microsoft's fiscal year ending Jun 30, 2016 (which began Jul 1, 2015).
- dump100 11y agoPerseverance is one of the key MS strength, they don't easily give up once they start, considering their history of getting things right by v3, it makes sense. There are exceptions, but still MS is a company mostly for long haul.
- Tloewald 11y agoThis is definitely a MS strength, although there have been some notable exceptions (e.g. Silverlight and Expression Studio).
- mmastrac 11y agoFirst of all, this is a beautiful piece of hardware. I hate that I have to ask this, but do these ship with locked bootloaders? If they don't, they might be a candidate for beautiful Hackintoshes or Linux laptops. I just can't bring myself to run something that isn't unix under the hood and OSX has been a pretty decent balance of openness/unixness/ecosystem with a pretty nice looking UI and a thriving software market. I haven't tried Windows 10, but I suspect I'd be just as unhappy with it as I was with Windows 9 on a Surface. I'm still a fan of the MacBook hardware, but a detachable screen is something you just won't see out of the Apple camp. I would love to have a laptop that converts into a tablet for light use/presentation/travel. A Hackintosh would be ideal, but I'd easily consider a Linux distro if it meant I could use something like this. It didn't ship with USB-C ports (shame), but it sounds like you might be able to buy an upgraded "bottom" and take advantage of that when it ships (that's huge!): http://thenextweb.com/microsoft/2015/10/23/surface-book-user-upgrade/ http://thenextweb.com/microsoft/2015/10/23/surface-book-user...
- DIVx0 11y agoI'm in the same camp as you. I really like this hardware but I don't want to use Windows. I don't think we'll see any good support for all of the modes it can operate in on other operating systems though at least not for a long while and then in very limited capacity. Me not wanting to use Windows is more about unfamiliarity with what modern windows is like for a non MS centric developer. My previous experience dates back to the XP days where trying to do anything other than MS things was a chore. I _really_ like the surfacebook, maybe it's time to take another look at windows?
- mmastrac 11y agoI think the biggest barriers to me would be the awesome package ecosystems in unix land (mysql, postgres and mongo are all a single "brew install" away!). I also would miss working in bash in iTerm and/or Apple's Terminal. Unless they've done a lot of work on the command prompt, it'll be moving back into a world of pain.
- 11y ago
- dump100 11y agoHas anyone used touch screen as a whiteboard during skype call or teleconf, how good it is? Sometimes, a real whiteboard is not good enough with camera.
- scrumper 11y agoSort of. I used to use a cheapo Wacom tablet with a painting app for online WebEx demos a few years ago; I'd flip from whatever thing I was demo'ing to a new desktop with a blank raster file open and draw explanatory diagrams. It was actually pretty decent. Having a pen integrated into the device, with some sort of transparent annotation overlay app would have been pretty exciting for me back then (not least because I wouldn't have to hand write text!).
- michaelbuddy 11y agoI would think rarely would a normal on the wall whiteboard work well with a webcam on a teleconference, but then again I've never had a meeting room that worked for much of anything teleconference-related. Always something wasn't right, lighting, space, noise etc.
- soylentcola 11y agoNot so much a touchscreen but I've used plenty of stylus/digitizer setups for this purpose over the years and they work as well as you'd expect. At one job, we used normal PCs with simple Wacom tablets for annotation of slides during love Adobe Connect sessions and the only complaint was from some users who hadn't yet become comfortable with looking at a monitor while drawing on a surface (sort of like learning to use a mouse or touch-type for the first time). At my current job, we have Sympodium monitors at lecture podiums so you can draw directly on the screen. These are also not touch screens but make use of an active digitizer like the Surface products and traditional drawing tablets. Likewise, I've got a Gen 1 Surface Pro which works just as well for the same sort of thing. Basically, as long as framerate doesn't need to be as high as video, it's fine. Usually the "slides" portion of those conferences (whether web-based or using VTC appliances) is set to use a lower framerate for bandwidth purposes while the "camera" portion will attempt to hit more video-like framerates. But otherwise, it's pretty useful and something of a standard in the educational live conferences I've worked on.
- otterpro 11y agoFor Surface Books, the price point seems to be off. It's priced higher than Macbook pro, and thus I have to justify the need for SB's exceptional portability. A MBP with i5/128GB typically sells for $1299 (but often cheaper from non-Apple online stores) , while the similar spec SB costs $1499. A MBP i7 costs $2000 while SB costs $2700+. I'd also want it to be Unixy, so my thought is to just run VM and use the Windows 10 only as a VM host, but nothing else. However, that'd be kind of a waste for such a machine.
- Tloewald 11y agoIt's not really exceptionally portable either. It weighs nearly twice as much as a Macbook.
- cmacpher 11y agoThe macbook is absurdly light. The Surface book weighs a little bit less than the 13 in macbook pro. The surface book competes with the macbook pro 13 more directly in terms of performance and price.
- wlesieutre 11y agoIt also weighs more than an iPhone, but that's not what it's competing against. One is a "pro" geared laptop with a discrete GPU, the other runs on a 4.5W Core M. Of course it's lighter! Microsoft has positioned the Surface Book against the Macbook _Pro_ pretty explicitly. EDIT: For the relevant size comparison: Surface Book 3.34 lbs Macbook Pro (13") 3.48 lbs I'd say MS did a great job in the weight department. Especially considering that their screen is bigger (0.44" taller, 0.04" narrower) and has 1.5x the pixel count (6 million vs 4.1 million).
- Someone1234 11y agoIt weighs 3.34 pounds (inc. Keyboard), a Macbook Pro 13-inch weighs 3.48 pounds. So, no, not twice as much at all. Quite comparable in fact.
- SyneRyder 11y ago
- neals 11y agoI love MS and will have a SP4 tomorrow. I was blown away by the Surface Book presentation and my first reaction was "I want one". But if you think about it, the product makes no sense. The bottom part holds all the battery, so you want to have it attached. But the top part has 3 hours of portability, so you don't want to have it attached. But the bottom part has a dGPU, so you might need that, some times. But the top part runs very well without the dGPU, so you don't need that. It's just weird to me. It just wants to be everything I don't need. I'll take my SP4 with a dock and a keyboard and be just as happy.
- criddell 11y agoYou make it sound like it's two cup holders away from being a Homer J. Simpson design.
- neals 11y agoNow there's a product I'd buy!
- IanDrake 11y ago>It's just weird to me. It just wants to be everything I don't need. With a dock both the book and surface 4 can replace your desktop. The question is, when you're not in desktop mode, do you want an awesome laptop experience with a lesser tablet experience or an awesome tablet experience with a lesser laptop experience? My wife's Surface comes today, but I got the i7, so the wait is on. ;)
- mikhailt 11y agoIt makes no sense because it doesn't fit your needs. If you want a tablet you can hold all day long and switch to a "laptop" for a few hours, SP4 makes sense. If you want a laptop but for a few hours a day, you'd want a light tablet to read or do research on, Surface Book makes more sense and the clipboard is much lighter than the SP4 as well. In addition, you can rotate it around while attached to the base to use it as a drawing surface as needed. SB/SP4 strikes a difference balance for different people. For me, I use my tablet as a content consumption device all day long and rarely type, so SP4 makes more sense than SB for me.
- xixixao 11y ago2 points: Panay's presentation was the best presentation from MS I have ever seen. It was about 100 times better than any MS presentation I have seen so far. Second, this is a nice write-up, and it is a promo, but for some of its honesty I'm surprised it makes out the SB as such a miracle. It is not particular thin and that might matter more than a lack of a kickstand.
- raylan_givens 11y agoDoes anyone have a source or any numbers on how Microsoft's revenue is split among its departments? I'd be curious to see how much of their revenue is from their hardware vs. software now.
- dcohenp 11y agoApparently hardware would be under their "More Personal Computing" Segment: https://www.microsoft.com/Investor/EarningsAndFinancials/Earnings/SegmentResults/P3/FY16/Q1/Performance.aspx https://www.microsoft.com/Investor/EarningsAndFinancials/Ear... They don't break it down per-product, but the whole segment was $9.1B revenue out of $20.4B for the quarter. And the only hint we get about this product specifically is: "Devices revenue decreased $1.8 billion or 49%, mainly due to lower revenue from phones, driven by the shift in strategy for the phone business, as well as lower Surface revenue. Phones revenue decreased $1.5 billion or 58%, as we sold 5.8 million Lumia phones and 25.5 million other non-Lumia phones in the first quarter of fiscal year 2016, compared with 9.3 million and 42.9 million sold, respectively, in the prior year. Surface revenue decreased $236 million or 26%, primarily driven by the release of Surface Pro 3 in June 2014."