5 ms·
If you're going to draw such sweeping conclusions about how obviously evil the right half the people in the country are, you should probably avoid doing it from
by jerf 11y ago
If you're going to draw such sweeping conclusions about how obviously evil the right half the people in the country are, you should probably avoid doing it from third-hand reports on Slate. It's more than a wee bit probable they're stacking the deck.
Personally, I'd observe that if "he has sold all his stocks, emptied his retirement accounts, and mortgaged his two properties—including a $1.2 million home with a view of Puget Sound—and poured the $3 million he raised into Gravity." actually translates to "all that was necessary to fuel this", then it isn't exactly out of line to complain that a grand unsustainable stunt being used for the purpose of trying to force this on everybody else is a very silly thing to do, and has little to nothing to do with the problem of "wealth inequality". Everybody already knows that if it were possible to just pull wealth out of thin air everybody could have more. The problem is precisely that it isn't.
If it does turn out to be sustainable, then of course more power to him, but I'll wait for that judgment when the millions of dollars have run out and either have or have not been replaced by revenue. Seriously. I will in fact wait for that. Paying people well doesn't bother me, and I doubt it actually bothers anybody. But I'm certainly skeptical in a way that, say, a report from left-wing Slate about how this didn't work would leave me less skeptical, because they'd clearly be reporting it against their will, and probably have examined it within an inch of its life.
And even through what I would consider substantial bias, the article's own text leaves a lot of room to be concerned about this maneuver. He's basically spending almost the entire profit of the firm on salary, then promising not to lay anybody off or cut salaries even if times turn bad. Well... guess what that translates to... if the company hits problems, he'll end up going out of business and these people will suddenly not have their jobs at all. Or his glittering promises that you're so excited about will turn out to only have been words. Or something that does not involve everybody keeping their jobs at way above-market pay in a company that can't make payroll.
He's welcome to do this experiment, but maybe we should all wait to make sure it succeeds before getting too excited about it, and demanding that anyone who thinks it likely to fail consider themselves bad people who should feel bad. All the best to him (again, no sarcasm at all), but the most likely outcome is that he goes out of business in the next recession.
- jfindley 11y agoA company has a finite amount of money to spend on payroll. The less you can get away with paying the low and middle level employees, the more you free up for the higher level employees. Part of the reason high-end salaries have increased so much is because low-end salaries haven't significantly increased at all. An experiment that drastically raises low-end salaries can therefore be viewed as a big threat to those whose wealth depends on being able to get away with paying their employees low wages. We can all argue endlessly about what constitutes a low wage, to what degree we should let the market decide, etc, etc - but the idea that "If there was more money available, we'd happily use it to raise entry-level wages instead of giving it to the top-tier employees" is demonstrably false. This is why this has everything to do with wealth equality.
- jerf 11y agoI have no idea what your reply has to do with me. I never even remotely made that claim. Were you so sure you knew what I was going to say that you didn't bother to read what I actually did say? A solution that can't be sustained isn't a solution. It is a category error to treat it as a solution merely because you like it, or it flatters your politics, or it makes you feel good, or it provides you a cudgel with which to hit your political opponents. None of those things will prevent the company from going out of business, if it does, and then nobody has a job.
- jfindley 11y agoYou asserted: > Paying people well doesn't bother me, and I doubt it actually bothers anybody. To which I pointed out that it might well bother some groups of people. You also asserted that: > ... has little to nothing to do with the problem of "wealth inequality". Everybody already knows that if it were possible to just pull wealth out of thin air everybody could have more. To which I pointed out that it does in my opinion have everything to do with wealth equality, sustainable or no, as this experiment is (IMO) primarily about where and how payroll gets distributed, not about how large payroll might be. I read your post carefully, several times, before replying. Please do mine the same courtesy. Thanks.