4 ms·
I recorded all of my phone calls with the person from Epic’s legal department. I knew that without his acknowledgment of the recording that the call itself migh
by ilamont 11y ago
I recorded all of my phone calls with the person from Epic’s legal department. I knew that without his acknowledgment of the recording that the call itself might not necessarily be admissible in court (depending on the state statutes), but knowing how fallible memory is, it would still provide me the ability to revisit exactly what was said on the calls and help me prepare for a legal battle if it came to that.
Besides the question of whether or not the contents of a recorded conversation is admissible in court, is it even legal to record a phone conversation without the other person’s knowledge?
- Natsu 11y agoDepends on the state... and in one state, it depends on whether or not you know it's illegal. I forget which state, but it came up a lot in the news during the Monica Lewinsky affair.
- jmiwhite 11y agoThis guide is slightly old (Last updated May 2014) but seems fairly comprehensive: http://www.dmlp.org/legal-guide/recording-phone-calls-and-conversations http://www.dmlp.org/legal-guide/recording-phone-calls-and-co...
- kjackson 11y agoI believe in some states it's a criminal offense to record phone conversations without the person's knowledge. So I would be very careful about doing this.
- oasisbob 11y agoYes, in some states it's legal to record telephone calls with the consent of a single party. I read his disclaimer as "I'm in a one-party consent state, but the person I'm talking to may or may not be - and I have no idea how admissible this would be as evidence but I'm pretty sure I'm not breaking the law."
- larrys 11y agoWhat matters is the state that you are making the recording in. So if your state is a one party consent state and you are one of the parties it doesn't matter what the rules in the other state are. Now what could get interesting is if you are in a one party state and you are calling on a cell phone and you hit a tower in another state. So then you claim that you are in State A and if they were to put in the effort to check or cell records they saw you hit the tower in State B then I would guess you would have to offer further proof of actually making the call in State A other than your statement that was the case. (As opposed to a land line where it's clear where you are located). http://www.dmlp.org/legal-guide/recording-phone-calls-and-conversations http://www.dmlp.org/legal-guide/recording-phone-calls-and-co...
- deftnerd 11y agoI also wonder if it's where the person who initiated the recording is, or if it's where the recording is taking place. If it is where the recording is taking place, a VoIP provider could do all the recording on servers in a state friendly to the recording, regardless of where the participants in the call are.
- rahimnathwani 11y agoWhat if you just route all your calls through a VoIP server in a one-party state, and record the call there?
- larrys 11y agoInteresting thought. [1] Probably doesn't fill the letter of the law. Otoh that is what I would call "a leg to stand on". That is it gives some wiggle room and reasonable doubt that you weren't following the law. Would depend on the exact wording of each States law and how tight it was. Ianal but often things boil down to this type of thinking with other things as you probably know. [1] For that matter what if you conference in a friend and the friend is the one that did the recording.
- tzs 11y ago
- chrsstrm 11y agoIn these types of situations it doesn't even make sense to try and surreptitiously make a recording of the call. I routinely record _all_ calls between myself and attorneys, accountants, advisors, partners, etc. and after asking permission to record not a single time has any of these people denied me permission or even questioned why I would record the call. Most people even appreciate receiving a copy of the conversation afterwards as well. In business situations like this, asking to record a call for records purposes is not an anti-pattern and you shouldn't be afraid to ask the other party for permission.