4 ms·
To believe that associating philosophy with science is pie-in-the-sky ridiculous is to profess ignorance of the foundations and history of science. Science is
by colordrops 11y ago
To believe that associating philosophy with science is pie-in-the-sky ridiculous is to profess ignorance of the foundations and history of science. Science is a descendant of philosophy and the decisions made on how we practice it and interpret its results are guided by different philosophies throughout the centuries. A book or course on the philosophy of science, which is offered by most major universities, is recommended.
- pierrec 11y agoYou make a good point, but where did I say that I believe that associating philosophy with science is pie-in-the-sky ridiculous? What I did say is that the metaphor is weak without bringing precision to how it should be interpreted, and your particular interpretation is sensible but a bit forced. Does being the progenitor of science make philosophy the thumb of the hand? No, there may have once been a time when that metaphor was applicable, but I wouldn't say that it's the case today. As for the idea that philosophy guides decisions on how we practice science, well... a book or course on the forces of economy, which is offered by most major universities, is recommended.
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoWhich is funny because economics is to a large extent a branch of philosophy.
- mannykannot 11y agoPhilosophy was, of course, the progenitor of science, but it is harder to find current relevance. For example, was science in a state of confusion until Popper corrected the errors of the logical positivists? Did the development of plate tectonics have to wait until Kuhn explained the structure of scientific revolutions?
- igravious 11y agoIt is popularly said that those who are ignorant of history are doomed to repeat its mistakes. I wish there was a similar cautionary expression for those who are ignorant of or dismissive of philosophy. Why is there such a vocal minority nowadays who claim that philosophy has had its day? Can you explain your reasoning please?
- mannykannot 11y agoThe burden of proof lies on you - any philosopher worth his salt could tell you that, and also that a popular maxim does not an argument make. Maybe you could start with the two questions I gave in the post you are replying to.
- igravious 11y agoAnswer A: Are you assuming that the philosophy of science is a done thing? It would be wrong to look back from our vantage point and make that conclusion. It matters not which theoretical improvement or refinement of the scientific method you point to if you forget that. Answer B: Kuhn's text uses the history of science to come to a philosophical (not a scientific) conclusion about scientific progress. Hence, Kuhn's text is philosophy of science and as such your question fails to make the point you think it is making. Now, how about answering my two questions? :)
- mannykannot 11y ago>Are you assuming that the philosophy of science is a done thing? Quite the contrary - I am giving an example that is supportive of the view that, while philosophy was instrumental in the development of the scientific method, it is no longer playing that role, and has not for some time. The second question is another example in the same vein. >Now, how about answering my two questions? You haven't discharged your burden of proof - all you have done so far is to talk around it. In fact, that is all you have done with the two questions I posed, rather than answer them directly.
- igravious 11y ago> I am giving an example that is supportive of the view that, while philosophy was instrumental in the development of the scientific method, it is no longer playing that role, and has not for some time. The second question is another example in the same vein. 1st: For example, was science in a state of confusion until Popper corrected the errors of the logical positivists? Ideas concerning the scientific method are less clear before Popper assuming you buy into Popper, that much is true, that much is true of any advancement in the philosophy of science. What is not true is that before an advancement lay confusion and after the removal of confusion. Progress wends its way slowly, incrementally, with ideas gaining clarity bit by bit. So it has gone and presumably so it will continue until someone presents an argument that the process of the improvement in our understanding of the scientific method is complete. That proof is for you or someone to provide, not I a proof of its counter-claim. 2nd: Did the development of plate tectonics have to wait until Kuhn explained the structure of scientific revolutions? No. And you know the answer is no. But so what? If Kuhn is right about how scientific thought progresses it could have an impact on how scientific bodies organise themselves and how funding is allocated and so on, which would have an impact on science at a much larger level than individual hypotheses and theories. Which shows that philosophy of science is still relevant.