4 ms·
I think the assumption that all writing is or should be an attempt to change someone's mind is misplaced. Despite the contortions to equate it to high art or so
by pvg 17y ago
I think the assumption that all writing is or should be an attempt to change someone's mind is misplaced. Despite the contortions to equate it to high art or some form of self-actualization, programming is mostly work and work, along with its rewards, involves a fair amount of frustration. Writing and reading about those experiences can be quite interesting and informative and the spleen vented also serves as good reminder not to take oneself (and one's tools) excessively seriously. Tastes vary but I know I'd rather read, say, a chapter in the Unix Haters Handbook than yet another wide-eyed post about the inimitable ecstasy of being within 12 feet of a Rails app.
- jacquesm 17y ago> Unix Haters Handbook I'm going to have to look that one up. You have to be thoroughly familiar with something in order to properly hate it.
- pvg 17y agoIt's a classic. The web site is here http://www.art.net/~hopkins/Don/unix-haters/handbook.html http://www.art.net/~hopkins/Don/unix-haters/handbook.html and includes the text of the chapter 'The X Window Disaster'. First hit when googling for the book name itself is a pdf of the whole thing (of indeterminable legality).
- jacquesm 17y agoThanks for spoiling my productivity ;)
- pvg 17y agoIn the middle of a conversation about, among other things, not taking things too seriously, someone downvotes a comment of obviously lighthearted intent (comes with a convenient emoticon!). Sometimes I suspect there's a secret HN Cabal dedicated to the smushing of any hint of levity.
- jacquesm 17y agoHave you ever seen or used the bellcore 'mgr' windows manager ? Besides the plan 9 stuff I thought that was one of the most elegant attempts at making a window manager, all the interaction was through stdin / stdout.
- mechanical_fish 17y agoI agree, but would note that high art and self-actualization are also mostly work. And, in fact, there are lots and lots of Haters' Handbooks for high art and self-actualization as well. To pick an example at random: I am given to understand that one of the routine tortures of classical musicians is to play Pachelbel's Canon, a thoroughly tedious earworm that is requested at nearly every chamber-music gig. One of my friends in college ran a classical music radio program called Anything but Pachelbel. And there's a very fun section of Robert Greenberg's lectures, How to Listen to and Understand Great Music, which could easily be retitled The Pachelbel Haters' Handbook. And one could definitely write The Science Haters' Handbook. The author of Piled Higher and Deeper is doing a marvelous job.
- jamesbritt 17y ago"I think the assumption that all writing is or should be an attempt to change someone's mind is misplaced." I'm more fond of writing that seeks to get people thinking and talking about things than proving this or that is The Truth. A problem with limiting writing to persuasion is that it requires you to first pick a side or figure enough out to know when something is better or worse than something else. But what if you can't? Often what's needed is more discussion, more people kicking around more ideas. Sometimes getting people rattled is what's needed to provoke interesting responses to move things forward.