3 ms·
If you live in Washington state, please support Initiative 1401 (http://saveanimalsfacingextinction.org http://saveanimalsfacingextinction.org, http://ballotped
by adamnemecek 11y ago
If you live in Washington state, please support Initiative 1401 (http://saveanimalsfacingextinction.org http://saveanimalsfacingextinction.org, http://ballotpedia.org/Washington_Animal_Trafficking,_Initiative_1401_(2015) http://ballotpedia.org/Washington_Animal_Trafficking,_Initia...) on the November state ballot (you have until Nov. 3 to submit your ballot). This initiative will help with reducing the amount of illegal wildlife products coming to the US. Most of these products come to the US from Asia so ports in Washington state are a prime destination for the ships smuggling these products. California has recently passed a similar law.
- sharkweek 11y agoAs a Washingtonian, I'll be voting yes on 1401, but I have a general question for the crowd here. Paul Allen has donated millions of dollars [0] to make sure this initiative gets through, which I think is great in a vacuum because I agree with what it accomplishes. However, in general I am against the concept of one individual person driving the success of an initiative because they feel passionate about a specific issue. Is it more acceptable when the issue is seemingly benevolent? [0] http://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/politics/paul-allen-backs-state-ban-on-rare-species-trafficking/ http://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/politics/paul-allen...
- mikestew 11y agoFlip it around to Eyeman's initiatives, which when not being soundly turned down by voters, get overturned in the courts. My point being, even if it's one individual driving it, it's still one-person-one-vote (and the courts act as a buffer for when we collectively make a bad choice). I don't care who's behind 1401: is it a good idea or not? In this case, I vote "yes" regardless of what drove it. In the case of all of the Eyeman-driven "advisory votes" (what a waste of paper and ink), I vote "no" (which translates to "maintain" on the ballot) across the board.
- wtbob 11y agoI'll be an opposing voice: please vote against Initiative 1401, which alienate the property of those who already own such items, and further reduces the incentives for those who live near such animals to farm them, rather than to poach them. Elephants are endangered because they are not owned; cattle, for example, are not endangered because the demand for them is profitable. The right thing to do, if one wishes to preserve endangered species, is to make it possible for people to legally raise, own and harvest elephants, rhinoceroses, tigers and the like.
- danpat 11y agoThis is an unfortunate truth. I suddenly found myself finding big-game hunting a whole lot less morally repugnant when I realized that the big money that goes into it is very much used to keep many species alive. Operators of paid hunting areas have a very strongly vested interest in keeping their revenue stream going, and thus, in keeping viable populations around. I am not pro-hunting by any means, but given a world where wildlife is hopelessly outmatched by man for resource competition, the only way to keep endangered species populated is to harness some aspect of humanity to fight for their preservation in ways that matter. Paid big-game hunting and animal cultivation is an effective way to do that and should be done more. The conflict between man and wildlife is one-sided enough that blanket "protection" is not sufficient to save many animal populations. They need active cultivation and encouragement if they're not to be wiped out through attrition (via illegal poaching, loss of habitat, etc). Simply making it more illegal isn't going to prevent that.
- adamnemecek 11y agoThis works nicely in theory, but (just like with other humanitarian efforts in the region) there is no way of ensuring that the money the hunters pay actually ends up funding conservation efforts and not some official's new car. This is the reason why the United States Wildlife Service has imposed a moratorium on imports of all hunting trophies from Tanzania and Zimbabwe. You can read more about it here http://www.fws.gov/international/pdf/questions-and-answers-suspension-of-elephant-sport-hunted-trophies.pdf http://www.fws.gov/international/pdf/questions-and-answers-s... There is nothing to indicate that the situation is dramatically different in other countries. Also your argument doesn't explain why the populations of many of the species protected by Initiative 1401 have been declining. If what you are saying actually works in practice, the populations should have been increasing.
- adamnemecek 11y ago> alienate the property of those who already own such items how does it alienate the property? > further reduces the incentives for those who live near such animals to farm them, rather than to poach them. why would they poach them if there is no market for ivory? > The right thing to do, if one wishes to preserve endangered species, is to make it possible for people to legally raise, own and harvest elephants, rhinoceroses, tigers and the like. Can you actually make a proposal how one would transition from the current state of affairs to the one you are proposing? Can you talk about some possible issues with your proposal? For example how would you prevent extinction of elephants in the wild?