4 ms·
Except it is not that simple. People have opinions about welfare without even interacting with individuals taking advantage of it. Have you directly stopped an
by rdtsc 11y ago
Except it is not that simple. People have opinions about welfare without even interacting with individuals taking advantage of it.
Have you directly stopped and talked to those people buying rugs? Or at a restaurant? Are you sure they are not just hipster kids wearing second-hand clothes but who might work at Google or have a rich daddy with a trust fund?. Maybe you did, but I doubt it.
So a lot of opinions and "feels" people have about welfare is what they are _told_ to have. By their parents, teacher, media, friends, TV, magazines, movies, etc.
I lived with a conservative family for many years, and I was of firm opionion that welfare queens are everywhere wasting pulblic's money and that's where all out taxes were. It was a very sincere and string opionion. But it was put in not head not my socializing with "welfare queens" but by White Middle Class Americans, who also didn't really socialize much with welfare recipients, but instead listened to Fox News all day every day.
So to make story short, it is about the "feels" but the feels are often easily updated/manipulated/used by whomever you let control your thought processes.
- JupiterMoon 11y agoThe OP's post when read carefully was actually a lot more nuanced than you give her credit for.
- rdtsc 11y agoCan you expand a bit on that?
- JupiterMoon 11y ago> Most sensible Americans are also fine with those same forms of "public assistance" being bestowed upon those same sections of the public for even extended durations of their lifetimes. I think sensible Americans get that the ill effects of an impoverished childhood & other social curses can stretch for the better part of a generation, if not more. This stuck out for me. I got the impression that she has mixed feelings about assistance programs but recognises their importance whilst wanting them to be applied fairly.
- rdtsc 11y agoThanks JupiterMoon! Yeah I agree with that point they made. I just didn't explicitly say it. I should have probably. What I focused on was the idea that it often boils down to a feeling. And I agree with that too, but I wanted to point that it is important how people arrive at those feelings. GP showed some example, but I didn't find those convincing. I think a lot of what people believe and think gets acquired and filtered through 3rd party sources (media, friends, parents, teacher etc). And even though a lot of people have strong feelings about welfare, they might not have gotten those from their own experiences. And then of course there are whole industries (marketing, pr, propaganda) whose goal is manage feeling, perceptions and ideas in others. Anyway, to recap I didn't disagree with their main idea, just wanted to expand on one part of it.