4 ms·
> Case in point: if a very popular Github repository (such as the one for the Linux kernel) decided to start using LFS for some of their files, they would insta
by paulddraper 11y ago
> Case in point: if a very popular Github repository (such as the one for the Linux kernel) decided to start using LFS for some of their files, they would instantly alienate all of their users. They would no longer be able to properly fork the project, or even clone it to get its binary files stored via LFS. Nobody would be able to send a pull request to Linus as a result without considerable effort.
Odd example. Linux doesn't use GitHub pull requests.
- Deinumite 11y agoYeah I am assuming OP doesn't realize that patches are sent to the Linux kernel through emails.
- megastep 11y agoI do, actually. I just noticed that there was a large Kernel git repo hosted on Github, and figured it would make a good example of a large, popular repository. I'm not surprised Linus is not actually using Github, so my bad for not stressing that this was more hypothetical than meant as a statement of fact.
- paulddraper 11y agoThere are literally thousands of uber-popular projects that are deeply integrated with GitHub. I recommend choosing one of those for an example. Line NodeJS or something.
- Jasper_ 11y agoThey still use pull requests, though, just in the form of email-based ones. https://git-scm.com/docs/git-request-pull https://git-scm.com/docs/git-request-pull
- jumpwah 11y agoExcept that's not a "pull request".
- Vendan 11y agoExcept it is. Just cause github does pull requests differently doesn't mean you can't do pull requests in pure git. Remember, git came before github.
- jumpwah 11y ago> Remember, git came before github. That's exactly my point. Using a "request-pull" instead of a "pull-request" will probably mean you can do this git-lfs thing with it. My understanding was that it was not working with "forked" repositories, which you need to have to make a "pull request". To make a "request pull" (or to just send a patch file), you don't need to "fork". ;)
- paulddraper 11y agoSure. With git-fu and enough emails, you can replicate anything done in GitHub. I'm just saying it's a very odd choice for an example of GitHub screwing over workflows.
- eridius 11y agoI would imagine that there's a number of people out there who still fork the GitHub mirror of Linux and use that to build their pull requests (which are then submitted via email rather than over GitHub, but which would presumably have the exact same issues). In fact, there are currently 10,532 forks according to GitHub.