3 ms·
Is there a reason for being unable to tell the difference between "r" and "l" that makes them special? Otherwise, as an italian, I have gone through the motion
by riffraff 11y ago
Is there a reason for being unable to tell the difference between "r" and "l" that makes them special?
Otherwise, as an italian, I have gone through the motions of learning to
* distinguishing long and short vowels in english. Ship vs sheep took me a looong time.
* going from ~7 vowels in italian to 14 in hungarian
* learning a few more consonant sounds in both hungarian, spanish, and english (I still suck at "h")
while I would agree they all still require conscious effort for me to produce them, distinguishing them is not a major issue with enough practice.
- alphonsegaston 11y agoAgain, the "cannot" here is probably imprecise. In Japanese, r and l exist as a single sound, making differentiation difficult for the average Japanese speaker in other languages. The original research by a Japanese linguist into this phenomenon in the 70s suggested it was impossible because of the way phoneme and allophone acquisition happens in childhood. But this claim had been mitigated by subsequent research that suggests it is context dependent, as well as less certainty about phoneme vs. allophone distinctions.