2 ms·
buro9 hit the nail on the head. The most important, often neglected, issue is that voters will understand and trust it. I've been digging through voting schemes
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
buro9 hit the nail on the head. The most important, often neglected, issue is that voters will understand and trust it. I've been digging through voting schemes for a while trying to find this one requirement. Fortunately, I did find one in a discussion on Schneier's blog:
Scantegrity voting scheme
https://web.archive.org/web/20110324052432/http://www.scantegrity.org/ https://web.archive.org/web/20110324052432/http://www.scante...
https://web.archive.org/web/20110728002210/http://www.scantegrity.org/learnmore.php https://web.archive.org/web/20110728002210/http://www.scante...
I'd still like to see experts in cryptography and voting architecture do a thorough evaluation of its security. However, the process is simple enough that about any location should be able to implement it and about any person use it. I mean, there might be modifications for accessibility reasons. Second link has the papers.
Anyway, what do you all think about Scantegrity in general and as a default recommendation for secure voting?
- specialist 11y agoI manually worked thru a hypothetical election using Punchscan for my jurisdiction. It didn't protect voter privacy. With paper ballots, dropping your ballot into the ballot box is the secure one-way hash (assuming enough people are voting). The trick crypto systems do is hide your ballot within a herd of ballots, using some kind of one way hash, assuming there will be hash collisions. Works great with simple ballots (few races) and large numbers of voters. Alas, in my jurisdiction, the smallest political (bookkeeping) unit is a precinct (ranging from 0-1000 voters) and our ballots have 10-40 races. So combinatorially, it's likely each ballot is uniquely identifiable. A crypto systems might work if our complex ballots were separated into more simple ballots. Eg one each for national, statewide, county, and local races. Rant: My primary grievance with proponents of crypto for voting is they do not specify under which conditions their systems will and will not protect voter privacy. That is very intellectually dishonest, with a dash of technophilia. After studying this, extensively, crypto based voting systems for elections are complete non-starter for me. I'd rather forfeit voter privacy than embrace an inscrutable system that I can barely understand.