4 ms·
Study: An aspect of language looks to be hardwired in our brains
- craigjb 11y agoSample size of 76....
- iopq 11y agoWhat does that have to do with anything? Statistic significance has to do with confidence intervals and sample sizes at the same time, so even a small sample size with a large effect has statistical significance, but a very small effect at a large sample size might not.
- colordrops 11y agoCould you point to a good article or tutorial on statistical significance, sample size, confidence intervals etc? I'd like to know how to analyze experimental results myself.
- cmarschner 11y agoStart here (and its references). https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statistical_hypothesis_testing https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statistical_hypothesis_testi...
- canjobear 11y ago76 is pretty large for a psych study and, if the effect size is large enough, a perfectly reasonable sample size to generalize from.
- riffraff 11y agobut in this case, to be able to generalize you would need speaker of many languages, otherwise it quickly becomes "people who know english can guess the meaning of adjectives". Moreover, I fear the same would still be true because they speakers would presumably already need to know english to participate in the study.
- hacker_9 11y agoI would have thought all living creatures with ears would assign the same meaning to loud/quiet or long/short sounds (i.e. loud sounds are more important as they signify a big predator, or a large object running/falling nearby. Small sound just confirm confirm 2 twigs collided when moved etc). With this common basis for sound, I don't think it is too suprising that our use of vocalisation relate in some way at the very basic level across languages.
- elijahz 11y agoHere's a fascinating documentary on the phenomenon: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-gwXJsWHupg http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-gwXJsWHupg
- sawwit 11y agoThis recent publication about evidence for a proposed model for basic grammatical processing in the neocortex, was also fascinating: http://www.pnas.org/content/112/37/11732.long http://www.pnas.org/content/112/37/11732.long An architecture for encoding sentence meaning in left mid-superior temporal cortex Human brains flexibly combine the meanings of words to compose structured thoughts. For example, by combining the meanings of “bite,” “dog,” and “man,” we can think about a dog biting a man, or a man biting a dog. Here, in two functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) experiments using multivoxel pattern analysis (MVPA), we identify a region of left mid-superior temporal cortex (lmSTC) that flexibly encodes “who did what to whom” in visually presented sentences. We find that lmSTC represents the current values of abstract semantic variables (“Who did it?” and “To whom was it done?”) in distinct subregions. Experiment 1 first identifies a broad region of lmSTC whose activity patterns (i) facilitate decoding of structure-dependent sentence meaning (“Who did what to whom?”) and (ii) predict affect-related amygdala responses that depend on this information (e.g., “the baby kicked the grandfather” vs. “the grandfather kicked the baby”). Experiment 2 then identifies distinct, but neighboring, subregions of lmSTC whose activity patterns carry information about the identity of the current “agent” (“Who did it?”) and the current “patient” (“To whom was it done?”). These neighboring subregions lie along the upper bank of the superior temporal sulcus and the lateral bank of the superior temporal gyrus, respectively. At a high level, these regions may function like topographically defined data registers, encoding the fluctuating values of abstract semantic variables. This functional architecture, which in key respects resembles that of a classical computer, may play a critical role in enabling humans to flexibly generate complex thoughts.
- ekidd 11y agoThe article makes some claims about childhood language learning: But some researchers argue that synesthesia, which appears in 4% of the general population, is actually an exaggerated manifestation of associations we all make from an early age—an ability most of us lose over time, and one that may help explain why children are so good at picking up other languages. I clicked through to the linked paper, and I could find no evidence that synesthesia provided any specific, significant advantages during childhood language acquisition. Now, other research supports that children do have real advantages when it comes to learning accents, and that they may have lesser advantages when learning grammar. But beyond that, the evidence becomes controversial. And adults who are socially and professionally immersed for, say, 5 years will often acquire a very solid command of a new language, especially if they're also voracious readers. In general, English-language media often overrates the ease with which children learn languages[1], and it's insufficiently critical about scientific theories which claim to explain this advantage. [1] Trying to raise bilingual children, for example, can be surprisingly challenging unless you live in a bilingual society.
- conceit 11y ago> no evidence that synesthesia provided any specific, significant advantages during childhood language acquisition because that was not claimed. The underlying capability forming connections, ie. exaggerated manifestation of associations and an ability most of us lose over time, is not itself synesthesia.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago> Now, other research supports that children do have real advantages when it comes to learning accents Childhood seems to be the only time when people can acquire certain new phonemes, in fact. Japanese speakers cannot properly learn to distinguish English /l/ and /r/ in later life. Other phonological distinctions are also difficult to learn in later life: tones, for instance.
- alphonsegaston 11y agoAnecdotally, I find this to be untrue. My wife, a native Japanese speaker who did not learn English until age 16, is able to distinguish between the two. I learned Japanese in my twenties and am able to pronounce the r/l phoneme. The only oddity I've noticed is that on rare occasions I've unintentionally made the r/l slip in English. Do you have a source for this?
- jack9 11y agoThe reason I thought ca-chook meant small is because it's fairly difficult to say. When saying small vs big, there's a few incentives (physical, contextual, etc) to have one easier to say than another. e.g. We have a big problem. We have a small problem.
- danblick 11y agoI thought küçük ("coo-chook") sounded small because it reminded me of baby cooing. I'm not really surprised by this result. Some words are imitative. Probably words that are more imitative are evolutionarily selected to remain in human languages because their speakers find them easier to recall. To me that seems like a perfectly good explanation for the phenomena that has little to do with "hardwiring into our brains".
- dreamfactory2 11y agodid they exclude esp?
- erispoe 11y agoThe main problem with the nativist hypothesis is that it's breaching Occam's razor rule. Is there a simpler explanation than being hardwired with information, which would be a fairly complicated thing to explain, considering what we know of the brain today? Yes, there is: languages are related and sound symbolism could be passed from language to language, or the perfectly reasonnable explanation offered by Christine Cuskley at the end of the article. In the world we live in, some set of sounds are associated to small animals, other to big animals. Nativist hypothesizes suffer from a lack of imagination in looking for alternative explanations. I cannot explain it? Must be innate! Or, children do it? Must be innate! Cognitive research points to a much more promising explanation: we are really good at learning, and we can learn abstract concepts pretty quickly, even as very young children. See Stanislas Dehaene's work for instance. Abstracting concepts for big and small from our environment and associating sounds with it is much more plausible than passing around information about abstract concepts in genes through natural selection based on random genetic mutations.
- oldmanjay 11y agoThat your argument is both an appeal to parsimony and imagination is slightly dissonant.
- erispoe 11y agoYou're right. Let's say it's a failure to consider the universe of possible explanations to select the simplest, by restraining yourself to the one you already like.
- copsarebastards 11y agoThat’s the danger of Occam’s razor and of simple answers. “Simplicity” is often a hiding place for our biases. We reach the conclusion we want to reach and then call it simple. --Plaza Garabaldi I'm not saying you're wrong, I'm saying that I don't actually agree with you that brains being hardwired with information is that hard to explain.
- erispoe 11y ago
- titzer 11y agoHalf the languages in the list are branches off the Indo-European tree. I have a hard time believing this is a result of "language hardware" in the brain as opposed to a much simpler explanation like the shared heritage of the words. They don't seem to have controlled for native language; E.g. Dutch has a lot of similarities with English...
- tokenadult 11y agoAs a reader of the article kindly submitted here who speaks and reads multiple human languages from more than one language family, I'm not convinced that this article passes the linguist's or polyglot's smell test. The sample size reported in the article is wholly inadequate for showing that there is a real effect here. That the underlying study was reported in a rather minor journal is a further indication that there isn't any real-world significance behind the statistical significance claimed by the researchers. For good background reading on why you shouldn't look merely to statistical significance claims for evaluating research on human subjects like this, see the articles by Uri Simonsohn[1] and his statistically astute co-authors, who have identified phenomena called "researcher degrees of freedom" (there are a lot of researcher degrees of freedom here) and "p-hacking" (a news release that mentions "more accurately than by random chance" is almost always a sign of p-hacking) that allow many weak, underpowered studies of human behavior to be published in journals with poor statistical skills among the editorial staff. [1] http://opim.wharton.upenn.edu/~uws/ http://opim.wharton.upenn.edu/~uws/ http://www.p-curve.com/ http://www.p-curve.com/
- canjobear 11y ago> That the underlying study was reported in a rather minor journal Cognition is one of the top journals in cognitive science. Definitely not a minor journal for this kind of work, and plenty of their reviewers are statistically competent. So my prior would not be that the stats here are bogus. I share your skepticism of their result about more synesthetic people being more able to guess the meanings of foreign words. The effect size there looks tiny, the motivation is a bunch of hand-waving, and I wouldn't be surprised if it doesn't replicate. On the other hand I'm inclined to believe their result that people can guess the meanings of certain foreign certain words with above-chance accuracy (about 60% for big vs. small). It's just a version of the well-replicated bouba/kiki effect[1], plus the idea that this can influence words in a language, which doesn't seem far-fetched at all. What I'm most concerned about is that people might be picking up on similarities between words beyond what the authors identify as "cognates". The sample languages are Albanian, Dutch, Gujarati, Indonesian, Korean, Mandarin, Romanian, Tamil, Turkish, and Yoruba. 4 of those are Indo-European and might have obscure etymological relations that show up as a few overlapping letters. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bouba/kiki_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bouba/kiki_effect