3 ms·
Rolling again, is no weakness at all. The next roll is also random and exactly as unguessable as the first. If the game was done 'without replacement' then the
by JoeAltmaier 11y ago
Rolling again, is no weakness at all. The next roll is also random and exactly as unguessable as the first. If the game was done 'without replacement' then the field would be reduced, but it isn't, and the field is unimaginably huge anyway. There is no effect whatsoever by 'rolling again' until you are happy with the result.
My buddy Tom always generates UUIDs by hitting the button several times. It gives him pleasure to 'waste' all those random numbers.
- DanBC 11y agoWith diceware there's a list of 7776 words. When someone rolls 1,1,1,1,1 and rejects that word they've cut down the word list to 7775 words. That's tiny, but it is a change.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoRight, for word choice it is significant. I was thinking, rejecting the whole password pattern.
- just_curioussss 11y agoBy rejecting a certain pattern you weakening the whole password scheme. It is no longer random, it is human chosen. An attacker can under certain circumstances exploit this behavior. For example, if they notice you are picking shorter words or words that consist of certain characters, they will have an easier time to crack the password. Whole categories or patterns can be rejected because of that, reducing the search space. An extreme version of your method, is picking only the patterns that relate exclusively to you, like picking your favorite music or hobbies. Then the whole scheme becomes useless.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoCurious notion. So, if a guy got that "human chosen" pattern randomly, they got rooked? He has a very breakable password, while the rest of us got good ones? Sounds like the whole algorithm is busted.