3 ms·
I've been wondering about password complexity for a while now. If a password is cryptographically hashed, so long as it isn't a dictionary word or date, why on
by chris_wot 11y ago
I've been wondering about password complexity for a while now. If a password is cryptographically hashed, so long as it isn't a dictionary word or date, why on earth do people add in complexity rules that prevent arbitrary character sequences?
What I'm getting at here is that if you had a 8 character password (for the sake of the example), and you can type in lowercase letters, uppercase letters, numbers and punctuation marks the total combinations of values is 95^8.
But then you remove all possible values of just numbers, all values that are just letters, all values that are just special characters. That reduces the set of combinations by (52^8) for alphabetic characters, then reduce further by 10^8 for numeric only values, then 33^8 for special characters. That's quite a few characters removed!
But then you get Apple's recent password requirement of no repeated characters in their iCloud and App Store passwords. My math behind permutations is a bit rusty, but that removes a hell of a lot of passwords as well.
On top of this, if you require at least one special character, alphanumeric character, and at least one number, then that reduces the number of possible passwords even further!
I've never understood how this made passwords safer... What am I missing?
- Natanael_L 11y agoThey assume people are using short stupid 90's style password rules. Which many unfortunately are...
- chris_wot 11y agoNot following...
- Natanael_L 11y agoStuff like aaa123
- chris_wot 11y agoWell, if you put in xuui-659995!?)) then it won't let you use this either. How does that make any sense? Edit: In fact, interestingly I used a pseudo-"random" generator made up in my brain. And there you have a big problem - I couldn't help myself but I grouped letters, numbers and special characters. I have to ask - if most of us do this, as we pick our own passwords, then don't we by our very nature make it easier to crack our own passwords?
- DanBC 11y agoPeople still think rainbow tables are a thing. So they add complexity to make rainbow tables too huge.
- chris_wot 11y agoI thought salting effectively nullified rainbow table based attacks?
- tomjen3 11y agoIt forces people to use Password1# rather than just password. There are many, many more people with an easily guessable password than there are with entirely random 8 char passwords.