4 ms·
This enthusiasm for taxation doesn't really motivate me to renew my subscription to the economist. There is something fundamentally wrong with taxing an absence
by cm2187 11y ago
This enthusiasm for taxation doesn't really motivate me to renew my subscription to the economist. There is something fundamentally wrong with taxing an absence of income. The French socialist party had a similar idea, they wanted to tax homeowners who occupy their property based on what rental income they would get if they were renting it out.
In London the primary cause of the housing crisis isn't unused lands. It is a combination:
1. very restrictive planning, which doesn't allow to build up except in a few limited spots. We end up with this absurd outcome of 3 storey houses everywhere and skyscrappers in 3 or 4 areas. Instead London would be much better off allowing to build 10 storey buildings everywhere.
2. Terrible infrastructure choices made decades ago which are now impossible to reverse. London has kept the narrow streets from XIX even when it had an opportunity to plan a better urbanism after the war. And the tunnels in the tube are too narrow to support the current traffic.
More taxes isn't really going to change any of that.
- humanrebar 11y ago> There is something fundamentally wrong with taxing an absence of income. I'd argue the other way, that taxing income is discouraging production. We should be taxing consumption more than we are. If you see deeded property as a non-renewable resource, then ensuring good use through taxation seems essential, not just a good idea. Now, land is not exactly non-renewable since we can build up, as you point out, but in densely developed urban areas, it's pretty close to non-renewable. We just had a land bubble, and many think the bubble is reinflating, at least in some areas. Putting a check on irrational pricing by adding a consumption tax here seems like a plan worth discussing to me.
- cm2187 11y agoIf you agree that there will be no further densification of already developped urban area (whether because of planning restrictions or physical constraints), then adding taxes isn't an incentive to better using the land. Which was the point of this tax. Preventing bubbles is another problem. I think in London the problem is that brits have this curious obsession with owning property and be willing to bid as much as they legally can, burrying themselves into debt, in order to achieve that. This is compounded with the lack of supply and foreigners using London property as a safe. But unless this obsession ceases, adding taxes or limits to borrowing isn't going to prevent bubbles. In fact the recent increase in stamp duty on expensive properties does not seem to have any effect.
- twic 11y ago> If you agree that there will be no further densification of already developped urban area (whether because of planning restrictions or physical constraints), then adding taxes isn't an incentive to better using the land. This is key. A land value tax would have to go hand-in-hand with measures to allow density to increase. That would mean changes in planning laws, and also building of infrastructure like transport, doctors' surgeries, schools, etc. The former can be done at the stroke of a pen, the latter can be funded from the increased tax receipts that come with higher density.
- cm2187 11y agoI agree but I don't think a tax would be needed where there is a strong housing supply crisis if planning restrictions are relaxed. Property developpers are already frenetically building residential skycrappers where they can in London.
- mrec 11y agoYou're not seriously holding up London as an example of a functioning housing market, are you?
- cm2187 11y agoI am merely suggesting that in the areas where there are little planning restrictions, the developpers do build the much needed housing supply.
- twic 11y agoMy point was that it's not enough to just build housing - you need to make sure the supply of public infrastructure increases accordingly. This is an existing problem in London, hence section 106 agreements and all that: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planning_gain https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planning_gain
- biehl 11y ago
- ZenoArrow 11y agoTo me, it's tackling the wrong problem. The issue with property is that they are being used as an investment opportunity, which undermines the purpose that most people want property for, which is as an affordable place to live. What we want to discourage is people using property to invest, but without penalising those who want somewhere to live. Therefore, if we're going to have a land use tax it should be based on how someone uses it. If a property is your only home anywhere in the world, then it should be exempt, but anything outside your main home could be taxed. That should discourage those people who buy property but barely live there from driving up prices for the people who want to live there.
- humanrebar 11y agoSo why not aggressively tax profits from property sales then? Tax-free primary residences causes at least two problems: 1. People want places to work and shop, too. 2. You end up having to regulate what counts as a primary residence so that Mr. O'Billionaire doesn't get an entire city block tax free. How does working from home affect your tax rate, etc.
- ZenoArrow 11y ago1. Taxes on companies could be adjusted to compensate for the introduction of a land use tax. 2. A primary residence is where you live most of the year. To have any property qualify you would need to spend more than 6 months in a year within a country, and would also need to specify which of the properties you own in that country is your primary residence. Problem solved.
- jrs235 11y ago*2b and only .25 acres of land would be exempt. (Of some other generally agreed amount)
- eru 11y agoNo exemption necessary. Just eg pay out all the land value tax as a basic income. And automatically anyone sitting on less than the average amount of land (in terms of value, not size), will get a net income. People sitting on more, will make a net payment.
- brador 11y ago> There is something fundamentally wrong with taxing an absence of income. Isn't the plan to eventually replace all fixed assets with rental assets? Thus solving this problem.
- mamon 11y agoSo, are we trying build some communist utopia where private ownership of the building is forbidden, all land belongs to government which rents it to a citizens?
- brador 11y agoYes, that is where we are heading. Not communism though, more like corporate ownership of everything. That is, corporations own the property since they exist forever, humans rent them, since their existence is transient. Remote working, minimalism, cheap flights, universal passport, home rental through Airbnb, Uber for travel. The pieces exist, they just need a little time to work through the system.
- MC7447a 11y ago> So, are we trying build some communist utopia where private ownership of the building is forbidden, No, the building is private property. > all land belongs to government which rents it to a citizens? Yes. The idea is that taxing land (not: buildings or property!) is less distortionary than taxing income or consumption. Hyper-capitalistic Hong Kong operates on that model. Property is expensive, but income tax is around 15% and consumption/sales tax is 0%.
- schoen 11y agoMany advocates of land-value taxation have proposed entirely replacing all other forms of taxation with it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_tax
- ZenoArrow 11y agoThe skyscrapers do seem a bit out of place in London, but I wonder if that's just a temporary issue. I remember reading that there were similar objections to the Eiffel Tower in Paris around the time when it was built. Perhaps they only look out of place because you remember what it was like before, or perhaps they'll always stick out. Are there limits placed on the heights of buildings in residential areas of London? As for narrow streets, I'm glad they kept them. Compared to some other big cities London feels more 'human friendly' (for want of a better term), wide streets can make a place feel more car focused, less a place that feels like a destination and more somewhere you travel through to get to where you want to be. Dedicated bike lanes are the only changes worth making IMO, but you can create that by working with the existing roads so long as you reduce the demand for cars. It seems that the London Underground has been increasing in capacity over the past 10 years or so, hopefully that will continue.
- cm2187 11y agoI am not a planning expert but my understanding is that pretty much the whole city is listed which means that the low rise houses can never be replaced. There are some areas that are not listed but then you have rules about panoramas, ie you need to be able to view certain monuments from many viewpoints, which creates an invisible web of max building height over London. As a result only a few spots can be built up. As for the narrow streets, I am not questioning their charm, but they make transportation very slow, and therefore make it difficult to build out to compensate not builing up.
- ZenoArrow 11y agoThis video captures quite a bit of what I consider important in city planning, would be interested to hear your thoughts on it: http://youtu.be/Hy4QjmKzF1c http://youtu.be/Hy4QjmKzF1c
- cm2187 11y agoI pretty much 100% agree with it. Except the 5 floors rule. Paris or Vienna are 7-8 floors. Upper manhattan is 10-12. And these do not feel particularly oppressive. Tokyo is another interesting type of urbanism. You have very large avenues delimiting blocks. The blocks can either be residential, in which case you walk in what feels like a quiet little village with its narrow streets. Or they can be "entertainment", with a dense web of noisy bars, restaurants and game arcades, lots of light and people.
- pjc50 11y agoProperty is income, just in a very illiquid form. Recently it's been quite possible for average homeowners in London to make more by property value appreciation than their salary. Property is widely considered the only form of investment that is safe and pays a decent return, while interest rates hover near zero. London could really do with a property tax that isn't capped like council tax. The recent SDLT changes are a surprising improvement, and there's even work being done on the "holding company" loophole. I'd suggest 1%, or 5% if the beneficial owner isn't resident in the UK for income tax purposes or is a company in a tax haven.
- cm2187 11y agoI see no justification for an exemption of capital gain tax on primary residence. This should be the way increase in property value should be taxed. If you realise that gain (like if you sell a stock), then you have cash that can be taxed. And property would become like any other investable asset. But it is absurd to tax someone on an income he doesn't have.
- petercooper 11y agoI see no justification for an exemption of capital gain tax on primary residence. Well, maybe if you get a "rollover" relief - but otherwise, such a tax would significantly lower the velocity of the property market (which is already suffering, not least because of a similar tax - stamp duty).
- eru 11y ago> But it is absurd to tax someone on an income he doesn't have. You have the income. It's just never hits the market. If you have your own property and live in it, you are producing and consuming `housing'. That can be taxed. Similar arguments apply for idle property. Opportunity costs are real.
- legulere 11y ago"restrictive planning" is not a valid argument. If rules don't make sense then you can criticize them directly. Maybe people don't like 10 storey buildings because they're ugly, they're impersonal, etc.?
- ThomPete 11y agoNot that it's any of my business at all but the very fact that you would even consider not renewing your subscription because they would write something you don't like doesn't really show much willingness to hear the other side but I will try to anyway :) I think you are ignoring a couple of things. First New York has skyscrapers everywhere still prices are sky-rocketing. So claiming that would solve Londons probems isn't really founded. Second as the article mentions. The value that someone accrue by owning land is 99% of the times based on the surrounding 99% of society increasing that value. If anything it's much fairer to tax the value of land because compared to income tax you aren't actually doing anything for that value. In New York right now. Chinese or buying apartments cash. Go to Miami and you will see plenty of amazingly expensive apartment complex be ghost towns because it's owners live in Brazil and just have it as a backup. The people who actually develop new areas with a few exceptions are artist and young people who make an area hip enough that developers want to a house here and there and slowly but surely push out those who made the area worth investing in to begin with. Who benefits. Some of the people who lived in the neighbourhood for a long time but had nothing to do with the increase in value of a place. Infrastructure choice isn't irreversible it just takes time. London wasn't bombed to anywhere close to the degree of a place like Berlin so of course it wasn't really going to change the width of the street. More taxes on land is solving the fact that urbanization is pushing people to move into the bigger cities. Again reasons unrelated to the fact that someone own land. There are plenty of ways to discuss taxation on land that would be both more effective and fair. There is nothing useful about people using property as an investment tool it just drive prices way up. We should reward money that work and tax money that doesn't.
- klagermkii 11y agoPeople may be okay with hearing opinions that differ from their own if they don't have to pay for it, but may feel quite differently if there is a sense that they are actively funding the writing and propagation of ideas that run contrary to their beliefs.
- ThomPete 11y agoSure but that is hardly something you can claim about the Economist. They go pretty wide on things. But sure if taxation isn't your thing then economist and most other magazine about economy isn't your thing either.
- tomp 11y ago> There is something fundamentally wrong with taxing an absence of income I disagree; in fact, I believe the opposite - that income is taxed way too much, simply because it's an easy target - "Look at those rich people drawing a huge salary!" In reality, people who have big salary are almost always not really rich - they are still employed by someone else, they can be fired at any time, and they don't own productive assets. In an ideal world, ownership of assets would be taxed way more than it's now, or e.g. income tax (all income, including capital gains and dividends) would be proportional to your current assets, not just your income (i.e. if a millionaire earns $1, s/he would pay e.g. 80% tax, while a poor student would pay 0%).
- cm2187 11y agoI fully support the concept of a flat tax on salaries, dividends and capital gains, but again all of these are realised income, ie you received cash, you can pay some away in taxes. But if you own a painting and this painting increases in value, this is not an income until you sell it. There shouldn't be a tax on "non income".
- lmm 11y agoThis notion of "realising" income is what drives a lot of complexity and abuses in the American tax system (e.g. companies doing stock buybacks when it would be more efficient to pay dividends, except they're taxed differently). If income were as simple as "net worth at end of year - net worth at end of last year" that could remove a lot of that. (Bonus: income which goes back to society via consumption doesn't count, and so there's a natural progressiveness to this model: the money that you spend on living this year isn't taxed, only what you gained on top of that). If your painting increases in value that's an indication that the amount of value that that painting could generate for the rest of society has increased, therefore the incentives should encourage you to sell it, not discourage you from doing so.
- eru 11y agoOf course, accessing the value of your painting is hard without a sale. Unless you require people to voluntarily put a price tag on all their paintings (and other assets) at which they'd be forced to sell to any comer.