7 ms·
We've Spent Billions to Fix Our Medical Records, and They're Still a Mess
- angersock 11y agoI've ranted elsewhere on this topic...but it's far, far worse than anybody realizes, and there is no incentive to make things better for patients. Every other factor is literally stacked against them.
- sachinag 11y agoYes. However! Government regulation could cut the knot. If HHS mandated standards for data at rest - since we never got a DICOM for charts like we did for images - the companies would have to write translates. When that happens, vendor lock in goes away and fewer people die.
- angersock 11y agoMandating a single, simple standard for medical purposes would probably be the best thing that they could do. I just don't have a lot of faith in it ever happening.
- hga 11y agoDoctors, too. One sentence in the stimulus bill mandating "meaningful use" of these mandated systems ballooned into ~700 pages of regulations, and a bunch of consultancies to help keep doctors and hospitals out of trouble, according to a friend in the field. And there are many related stories about doctors focusing on their computers instead of their patients as they fight with these systems (I kinda saw that once, but in all fairness the doctor had lost all her paper records in a tornado, I don't think she had anything left but her appointment book). In one worse case I read about, fighting the system until there were enough lights turned green. In general this is a very hard field, e.g. the U.K. NHS more ambitious effort was an abject failure: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NHS_Connecting_for_Health https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NHS_Connecting_for_Health
- meatysnapper 11y agoI know several doctors who have retired rather than deal with the EMR mess, and these are work 80 hours a week doctors, vs the new, gentler work regular hours kind. In addition, the doctors I know who continue to practice have had to reduce their patient hours due to the amount of time EMR takes up.
- sgarg26 11y agoMany hospitals went sold significant assets (like office building - assuring guaranteed rent) or took on loans to fund their EMR purchases. Hence, deals with these dollar amounts are tough to reproduce for many hospitals. Epic has made major strides in supporting connectivity between EMRs. Partially, through standards like direct - http://directproject.org/ http://directproject.org/. This problem will be largely solved in three to five years. Actually, a growing number of geographic regions of the US already have seamless EMR records exchange
- CCs 11y agoFrom the DirectProject blog, on 08/11/2011: "Moving on... It's been a fantastic ride"
- jhulla 11y agoCoding errors abound in this space. For example, you can go to the CMS.gov to lookup ICD codes. This is what you get when you lookup the word "finger" https://www.cms.gov/medicare-coverage-database/staticpages/icd-10-code-lookup.aspx?KeyWord=finger&bc=AAAAAAAAAAACAA%3d%3d& https://www.cms.gov/medicare-coverage-database/staticpages/i... It contains hundreds of entries. Here are just a few selected at random: S61.352S Open bite of right middle finger with damage to nail, sequela S61.353A Open bite of left middle finger with damage to nail, initial encounter S61.353D Open bite of left middle finger with damage to nail, subsequent encounter S61.353S Open bite of left middle finger with damage to nail, sequela S61.354A Open bite of right ring finger with damage to nail, initial encounter S61.354D Open bite of right ring finger with damage to nail, subsequent encounter S61.354S Open bite of right ring finger with damage to nail, sequela S61.355A Open bite of left ring finger with damage to nail, initial encounter S61.355D Open bite of left ring finger with damage to nail, subsequent encounter S61.355S Open bite of left ring finger with damage to nail, sequela S61.356A Open bite of right little finger with damage to nail, initial encounter S61.356D Open bite of right little finger with damage to nail, subsequent encounter S61.356S Open bite of right little finger with damage to nail, sequela S61.357A Open bite of left little finger with damage to nail, initial encounter S61.357D Open bite of left little finger with damage to nail, subsequent encounter S61.357S Open bite of left little finger with damage to nail, sequela S61.358A Open bite of other finger with damage to nail, initial encounter S61.358D Open bite of other finger with damage to nail, subsequent encounter S61.358S Open bite of other finger with damage to nail, sequela S61.359A Open bite of unspecified finger with damage to nail, initial encounter S61.359D Open bite of unspecified finger with damage to nail, subsequent encounter S61.359S Open bite of unspecified finger with damage to nail, sequela
- hga 11y agoWell, this is the notorious ICD-10 "upgrade" from ICD-9. Which has some "wonderful" codes, e.g. try https://www.google.com/search?q=icd+10+codes+funny https://www.google.com/search?q=icd+10+codes+funny Everyone's unfair favorite is "V97.33XD: Sucked into jet engine, subsequent encounter." Unfair because that doesn't mean you were stupid enough to do that twice, but had to see a doctor after the first visit. "W55.41XA: Bitten by pig, initial encounter" is OK, it happens. But "W61.62XD: Struck by duck, subsequent encounter." WTF??? I'm from a hunting family, and I've never heard of smallish birds like ducks harming people in this way. Ditto "W61.12XA: Struck by macaw, initial encounter" and "W59.22XA: Struck By Turtle" (now, being bitten by a big snapping turtle is horrific, but being struck by any turtle???). But this remains the most bizarre of all I've heard: "V91.07XD: Burn due to water-skis on fire, subsequent encounter." OK, at least we can laugh about ICD-10. For now.
- bossmojoman 11y agoThis is allowing companies like Kno2 to make quick inroads into the space though.
- methehack 11y agoIf you're interested in US Healthcare, I can recommend "The Healing of America: A Global Quest for Better, Cheaper, and Fairer Health Care". I was surprised to learn that France, for example, has private doctors, private hospitals, and private insurance companies (gee, somehow thought they had 'socialized medicine'). It spends half what the US does per capita and is ranked #1 by the WHO (the US is ranked #37, just behind Costa Rica). How do the French do it? Well, it's not that hard. All other developed nations using the Bismarck Model (like the US, feel free to google that or any of this) have a few structural differences from the US. The first is a particularly obvious one: insurance companies are non-profit (though privately held and operated). Fees are entirely standardized and printed for all to see ("reference pricing", structurally like medicare/aid). Doctors and hospitals make a lot less money (Doctors drive volvos not porsches). Doctors don't pay for medical school. Claims are never denied. Doctors are rarely sued. Doctors are paid very quickly (3-14 days). I'm not making this up. In essence, the system squeezes all of its players to be as efficient as possible. In the US, the exact opposite is true. Most of the players are incentivized to drive costs up. A private FOR PROFIT insurance company (which no other developed nation allows) by definition wants to suck all the money it can from the system and pay none of it out (to wit: when an insurance company pays a claim, it is called a "medical loss"). Hospitals are in an arms raise of acquisitions (to better negotiate with insurance companies) and over-built, fancy facilities (to attract patients and justify the exorbitant costs). Doctors start their professional career by having to pay off huge student loans. Insurance companies, hospitals, and (to a much lesser extent) doctors collude, in effect, to steal money from all the other employers out there (in insurance premiums) and from patients (co-pays, denied claims, and an ever-growing number of out of pocket expenses). None of this is the fault of insurance companies, hospitals, or doctors. It is entirely the fault of our incompetent no-account and utterly failed political system. US healthcare is corrupt because the US political system is corrupt. To fix it, we need to fix that. Entrepreneurs cannot fix US healthcare in the current regulatory environment. The incentives are completely wrong. EDIT: added a missed "system" after a "political". EDIT2: I forget to mention the most relevant piece. The French, since 1998, have had 'La Carte Vitale'. It is an electronic medical record they carry around with them. Every doctor's office has a reader. It is a government standard, government owner, and government operated. Epic makes money by _NOT_ sharing its data if it can get away with it. Switching costs are its friend. It's called 'vendor lock in' and its why the government should be doing this small piece of it. It's like building an interstate highway. It lets commerce happen.
- MDNukem 11y agoI'm surprised I don't see any comments about the FHIR api here. It's a project seeking to standardize a RESTful api for clinical encounter data that's gaining a fair bit of traction. If the existing EMR companies don't manage to subvert its goals, the problem of data interoperability will be largely solved within the next 5-7 years.
- mindcrime 11y agoThat's the best news I've heard in a while. I was just complaining earlier today, that I hate the way I have to login to so many different EMR systems to look at my medical records, and there's no interop between them, or (mostly) any convenient API to download data. I want record from my GP? FollowMyHealth.com I want records from my cardiologist? UNC's EMR system. I want records from my bariatric doctor? Duke's EMR system. I want records from my dermatologist? Yet another system. I want records from my othopaedist? You guessed it, yet another system. What I want is to be able to put ALL of my medical records, AND my "fitness" information (stuff from Strava, Fitbit, etc.) into one freaking place. This current setup is horrible. :-(
- doktor_k 11y agoThere are a few startups that do this. gliimpse picknick health
- mindcrime 11y agoHow would that work? The existing provider would have to provide an API or export feature, or else you'd be back to re-entering shit by hand. My problem is that most (if not all) of these existing systems seem to lack any kind of API or ability to dump data in a machine readable format. :-(
- kbranson 11y agoThey are using the view, download and transmit aspects of meaningful use 2. So they either scrape the portal or parse the downloaded file. The downloaded file is often a variant of c-CDa. However each portal can be different so I assume they are doing the epic and cerner (large dominant players) first.
- raverbashing 11y agoSo, what's the most common standard for PHR information? I've only heard of HL7 which is basically paying money for a bunch of XSDs (of course)
- methehack 11y agoIf I understand your question, probably a CCDA. I think the real problem is no system has a reliably comprehensive picture. After that, it is challenging to find a reliable global patient identifier. Epic says they have the health records of 175M americans. I would say they have parts of records of 175M americans and probably a lot of dupes.
- cordite 11y agoGiven that these numbers are individually sourced from customers, customers own their own data, and all interchange is P2P--there's not a good way to really count. Customers own their range of member-numbers as well. Plus, the whole thing about identity is even more difficult, you can't go by name, SSN, and DOB alone. As far as I know, HL7 is mostly used between internal systems within an organization. For sending actual patient data, allergies, conditions, CCDA is usually used for communication with non-Epic EMRs belonging to other organizations. As an aside, CCDA and HL7 don't support rich data well, so they usually end up as base64 encoded PDFs.
- cordite 11y agoThere are different versions of HL7. Currently the common one is some line and character delimited format, HL7 v2. {OBX,ORC,etc.} |data|||more data|number|||identifier| Which is basically a member of the multimap with the first word as the key, with an indexed map of text. It's not really a standard like HTML, at least no EMRs, interface systems, instruments, and so on abide by them. So, whenever systems hook up, there has to be setup / build to map what text means what to each other--although the positions are generally agreed upon. When interfacing systems together, there is both a legal and a technical cost that must be dealt with. With highly configurable systems on both ends, figuring out who's terms / categories equate on the other side and back is not an easy task and most organizations hesitate to go through with it unless necessary. The tools are there, it's just that when everyone customizes their own universe, it's unlikely to work out of the box. You can stick a german and a guy from holland together in the same room, they might have some shared words, but whether they can hold a coherent conversation in their native tongue is a different matter.
- maerF0x0 11y agoGiven we're 320M people you could say "we've spent billions" on many many things and not solved it. We've spent billions on food this week -- and we're still gonna get hungry! "Billions" is a scary sounding number that doesnt mean much anymore. Show me 10s and 100s of billions.
- Floegipoky 11y agoAthenahealth, the company I work for, makes cloud-based medical systems with a heavy focus on user experience and interoperability. Our More Disruption Please team is working hard to bridge the gaps in the healthcare continuum, and we do publish our API: http://www.athenahealth.com/developer-portal http://www.athenahealth.com/developer-portal Oh, and if you think your code's good enough to fix healthcare, we're hiring ;D
- cordite 11y agoIts a pretty challenging industry, isn't it?
- Floegipoky 11y agoYes, there's a lot of bureaucracy involved, and providers are picky users =)
- cordite 11y agoOh yeah, I definitely am aware of that one. I heard you guys were doing an initiative for getting providers up and running on Athena in 5 days. Neat stuff!
- ddw 11y agoYeah for the sake of healthcare I hope athena continues to grow. Keep up the good work!
- ddw 11y agoDefinitely not a fan of Epic but the article could have mentioned this: https://open.epic.com https://open.epic.com