3 ms·
>The problem with Fusion has always been that R&D associated with it has no bearing on any first order weapons technology. actually i think it is quite opposit
by trhway 11y ago
>The problem with Fusion has always been that R&D associated with it has no bearing on any first order weapons technology.
actually i think it is quite opposite - the inertial confinement approaches have from the start been the most promising, and they are relatively easy to miniaturize - thus paving the way for the neutron weapons without fission primary. No first-rate power - who already has nuclear weapons and thus has no real need for new types of neutron weapons - is interested in second-grade players obtaining such weapons bypassing the need for fission primary, as all the hurdles related to fission primary is what provides for non-proliferation.
Thus all the government funded research has been only in non-miniaturizable (as seen decades back) Tokamak and laser confinement. Sandia Z-machine (great inertial confinement approach) could have been burning DT targets at the end of 199x, yet they started to do it only 15 years later (at least officially) - somebody definitely wasn't in a rush :) With tremendous progress in solid state lasers i kind of curious what fate (ie. government funding) is waiting for NIF as upgrading its warehouse size 3% efficient lasers to container size 20-50% efficient solid state would obviously be in order. Yet it doesn't seems it is going to happen - the last monthly NIF's status update was in May 2014 and officially it has stopped ignition experiments and back to material research (simulating plutonium compression in the nukes)
- Florin_Andrei 11y ago> and they are relatively easy to miniaturize Wait, really? How?
- trhway 11y agowhile it is obviously a sarcasm, it suggests that there is need to point obvious difference between energy and power and its density. Inertial confinement schemas don't require large energy, they require huge power and power density though. I.e. a few joules in a femtosecond impulse concentrated in a few cubic millimeters volume. Reaching that power and density is just a pure engineering task, there is no hard physical limits preventing it as there are for example on the minimal size of tokamak.
- cstross 11y agoNit-pick: the problem with the Z-machine fusing D-T is that the D-T reaction kicks out a ton of neutrons. Once you turn a plasma research experiment over to actual fusion, you end up with secondary activation of the machine's core components, thereby turning them into high-level radioactive waste. This stops you tearing it down and poking around inside and reconfiguring it. This was the fate of the UK's JET experiment at Culham (the Joint European Torus, predecessor to ITER): once they finally bit the bullet and went to actual fusion containment experiments, the "hot" reactor became a lot less accessible for tinkering and reconfiguration. So you don't take that step until you're real sure you don't want to play with your plasma containment experiment any more.
- zardo 11y agoIt's hard to blame anyone for that. I don't know how the world would deal with hydrogen bombs that didn't take a huge industrial effort to produce. Probably by blowing each other up until no one could build them anymore.