2 ms·
I looked at the three competitors he listed in his letter and this describes his idea in a nutshell: The goal was to make a mobile app that worked something li
by Mz 11y ago
I looked at the three competitors he listed in his letter and this describes his idea in a nutshell:
The goal was to make a mobile app that worked something like; install, find your doctor, take a photo of your drivers license, “sign” on the phone (to validate identity) and then magically (after a few days time) you have copies of all your past health records, accessible on your phone. Obviously, we had many ideas of what you could do next (visualize your health history, find correlations and causation, compare with norms, share with others, enhance with other data…) but we wanted to make it fast, easy and free to get your records. After a few months, we had this working (with lots of issues) and it was really cool!
I am having trouble understanding why medical records are apparently central to his vision. Why? I mean, if you are frustrated with how medicine currently works, why not do something "non medical" as a real alternative?
- mfoy_ 11y agoNothing in his original vision seems off to me, of course I can see why people would be wary to share that with his service, though. (As he listed in the reasons for killing the project) >do something "non medical" as a real alternative What do you mean? Are you talking about alternative medicine?
- Mz 11y agoI worked in insurance for over 5 years. Medical records are regulated by HIPAA. Being HIPAA compliant is a pain and most people don't understand medicalese. But there are metrics you can track that can be medically significant and it doesn't require you to deal with doctor's offices or official medical records. Why not offer a means to track diet, blood glucose readings for diabetics, and other metrics of that sort? It addresses the domains he was targeting -- people with chronic illness or "optimizers" trying to improve their sports performance -- without getting into dealing directly with official medical records, HIPAA compliance, etc.
- mfoy_ 11y agoOkay, I see what you're saying now. Your original comment was a little confusing because it wasn't clear what you meant by "non medical". That would be a cool app but I doubt many people would able and willing to keep entering the data required to get meaningful results. Medical records would conceivably "skip" that process and you could just peruse your historical data. So it's a matter of convenience, I guess.
- Mz 11y agoPeople with chronic illness who take metrics regularly or people who are interested in optimizing their performance are both groups that can and will keep such data, if given a good means to do so. Sometimes even if they have really terrible means to do so.
- Animats 11y agoIt's a hard problem. Huge efforts are going into getting medical records into some machine-usable form without making medical care worse or overloading doctors. That alone is hard. Doing it across multiple providers is very hard. The business plan seemed to be "do cool app", and then magically the huge back-end problem somehow gets solved. Jim Clark, the founder of SGI, tried to do this in 1995, with Healtheon.[1] After several failures but a successful IPO (dot-com boom) which raised $40 million, the business pivoted into medical billing, and is now Emdeon, which does about half the commercial medical/insurance billing in the US. So bailing out at the seed round was a good idea. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Healtheon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Healtheon
- marktangotango 11y agoFantastic info, thanks for sharing. Great example of a pivot.
- fencepost 11y agoWithout doing some research I'm not sure that this could ever have worked anyway. Unless things have changed a lot in the last couple of years, medical practices are allowed to and generally do charge a non-trivial copying fee for providing records to patients; these fees have legally set base cost and per-page caps that I believe are updated yearly. I'm sure some of this has changed as offices shifted to EMR (Electronic Medical Records) systems, but many offices don't scan the entire existing chart into a new system - just the key parts relevant to current care (e.g. labs from the last 6-12 months, etc.). The full chart is still in a tagged manila folder on a shelf or in a box depending on the office. I've not regularly seen practices charge for sending records to other medical practices or for providing limited information to the patient directly (e.g. copies of labs), but that's usually not for an entire chart it's for items that can reasonably be faxed. Where I have seen practices charge it's when they also have a regularly scheduled outside service that comes in to scan entire charts that have been requested and for some specialties (e.g. neurology) those charts can easily be 500-1000 pages. I suspect that if a patient wants an entire chart transferred to a new practice that the old one will require that they request and pay for the copy, then it's the patient's job to get it to the new folks. Changing systems can also be a problem; I know of one specialty practice that has a firewalled-off 2003 server with their old EMR on it because when they migrated to a new system only demographics and some other basic information could be automatically imported. When previous patients schedule appointments, they go into the old system and export all the relevant records to PDFs, then import those into the patient's chart in the new system. Given the still-widespread need to either scan a bunch of paper, retrieve records from multiple systems, and pay for printing or burning to a CD I see no reasonable way for a company to offer that service free or even inexpensively. Update: here's a nice resource on per-state costs: http://www.lamblawoffice.com/medical-records-copying-charges.html http://www.lamblawoffice.com/medical-records-copying-charges... In Illinois, for example, it can legally cost you a minimum of $25 even for a single page, though as I noted most offices don't seem to have a problem with not charging for small numbers of pages.
- Mz 11y agoYeah, requesting records was a thing I did at my old job. I was allowed to pay fees up to a certain limit without it going to approval. Above a certain amount, my boss needed to approve the expense. We were an entirely electronic records based system. I think I reviewed a paper claim once in the 5+ years I was there. I had to get instructions on how to do that because I still needed to handle it via our computer system in order to be able to cut a check. So even with almost everything being faxed, digitized, etc. there were still fees to pay when requesting records. And I have reviewed claims that had hundreds of pages. It wasn't the norm, but if someone was in a serious accident that was followed by hospitalization and multiple surgeries, that did sometimes come across my desk. So, I agree with you. Requesting records is actually something of a pain, even with standardized letters and procedures developed by a large company with years of experience. And, no, it is generally not free.