3 ms·
There's some good stuff there, but this gets me: WHAT IS THE NEW ROUND OF FUNDING? (Required: Specify Seed, Series A, etc) WHO ARE THE INVESTORS?
by mindcrime 11y ago
There's some good stuff there, but this gets me:
WHAT IS THE NEW ROUND OF FUNDING?
(Required: Specify Seed, Series A, etc)
WHO ARE THE INVESTORS?
(Required)
HOW MUCH FUNDING (in $) DOES IT HAVE IN TOTAL?
(Required: Specify Seed, Series A, etc)
This suggests that really, the only thing they care about, is stories about people raising money. Like, that's the only thing that matters in the world.
In reality, who you're funded by is trivia. Yeah, I said it. It's fucking trivia. It's not going to make a difference in whether you succeed or not. IMO, to the extent that it matters, it's a microscopic factor.
You would think that a news outlet would be interested in the what of a company, less than "who's funding it?", ya know? I mean, if somebody has created a ground-breaking new app, (or something they think is ground-breaking) then the app either is news-worthy, or it isn't. You don't need to know who they're funded by, or if they're self-funded, to decide that.
I've said this before and I'll keep banging this drum until I drop... the goal of a startup is to make money, not to raise money. To the extent that you do the latter, it's in service of the former. But raising money is a tactical objective, not the end goal.
- ekpyrotic 11y agoMike is thinking about his readers here. TechCrunch is essentially a business-to-business publication, which provides market intelligence on technology companies. It might be 'sexier' than The Aluminium Times or Mining Today, but it's effectively serving the same role -- to inform the industry, and those working within it, about important sector news in a timely way. People who aren't strictly working in the industry read it too because they're interested in tech more generally, or getting involved in it, or want to know the coolest things to download. For that reason, TechCrunch publishes the occasional entertaining piece. But it's primarily purpose is to brief tech entrepreneurs, C-suite executives and VCs who are active in the industry. So, what are these people interested in? They are /absolutely/ interested in who is participating in funding rounds, as well as the level of their contribution. If I run a fashion start-up, for example, and spot on TechCrunch a story about another fashion start-up securing $5m in Series A funding, the first thing I'm going to ask myself is... who participated in this round? Then I can ping them an email to get on their radar. Who is investing is crucial market information for tech decision-makers. It's certainly not just a bit of trivia.
- mindcrime 11y agoIf I run a fashion start-up, for example, and spot on TechCrunch a story about another fashion start-up securing $5m in Series A funding, the first thing I'm going to ask myself is... who participated in this round? Then I can ping them an email to get on their radar. Sure, I'm not saying that it doesn't matter to somebody. But in the grand scheme of things, I don't believe it's that important. OTOH, I do believe there are people who think it's important, so in some indirect sense, it matters. But my point is just to say that it's hardly The Most Important Thing, especially compared to the meat of what the company is actually doing. IOW, if you've invented AGI, that's news-worthy regardless of whether you're funded by A16Z, Bull City Venture Partners, or your crazy uncle Bob.
- aaronbrethorst 11y agoTechCrunch is essentially a business-to-business publication, which provides market intelligence on technology companies I couldn't disagree more. Most charitably, it's Sports Illustrated for technology. If I run a fashion start-up, for example, and spot on TechCrunch a story about another fashion start-up securing $5m in Series A funding, the first thing I'm going to ask myself is... who participated in this round? Then I can ping them an email to get on their radar. Dear VC, now that you have skin in the game in this sector, please develop a conflict of interest by investing in my startup that competes with a company you've already invested in. Here's an example of how/why this doesn't work: http://www.bhorowitz.com/instagram http://www.bhorowitz.com/instagram
- manigandham 11y agoTechCrunch is not a B2B publication, it's much more consumer oriented. Most of their market intel is pretty far off precisely because they write about so much in generic/layman terms by writers who don't have strong industry niches. Investors have much better options for investment intel like CBInsights or Mattermark than TC. It's not a bad source of info, but not always reliable or accurate and definitely not a primary source for VCs/execs (outside of perhaps the SV bubble). A good example of B2B publications would be trade journals and sites like the IDG network that offer much more nuanced articles and insights with very focused categories.
- logicallee 11y agoHere is a thought exercise. God is looking at Earth and agrees with you, mindcrime. He says, "It's a shame people need to spend so much time raising money - raising is only a means to an end, I want my People to improve society for one another. So I will make a change - anyone can get an investment from me, no questions asked, but with one caveat -- I will look ahead (simulate the universe with my omniscience), and see if they succeed in building something big and good and useful and returning my money, in case I invest; if they will, then they get my investment, but if they won't, they don't. For example if a physicist (no business training) wants $1B to build fusion power plants, they'll get it as long as they will succeed and it'll be great for society and they will return my money." In this world, you do not need to convince anyone that your idea will succeed; you can just go ahead and build it, even if your idea requires investment rounds to execute on. This is not the world we live in.
- mindcrime 11y agoI feel like you're replying to something different than what I said, or at least what I meant to say. I'm not saying that no business should ever raise money. I'm not saying that some businesses don't need to raise money (maybe even large amounts of it) up front. I am saying that in any case, the actual raise itself is NOT the goal of the company. You're not successful when you raise a round. You're successful when you've built a profitable, sustainable business that can endure while carrying out whatever your original mission was. Unfortunately, a lot of things in "startup culture" these days emphasize fund-raising in such a way as to suggest that the raise itself is The Most Important Thing. I think that's an unhealthy mindset for everybody involved.
- logicallee 11y agoThe raise itself is the most important to any company that does not have an ability to meet its objectives without raising. The culture of financing determines what startups are possible. (i.e. the culture of financing divides the "set of startups that require a raise to execute their ambitions" into the group 'possible' and 'not possible'.) Just imagine how different the world would be under the scenario I outlined, in which this sorting does not occur.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]