4 ms·
It's a clever idea, but is the vision for this to have one hanging on the wall in a vast number of public places? It says there are 160,000 choking deaths worl
by mhb 11y ago
It's a clever idea, but is the vision for this to have one hanging on the wall in a vast number of public places? It says there are 160,000 choking deaths worldwide annually. Presumably the Heimlich maneuver would have worked on some number of those. What is the marginal number of lives saved and at what cost?
- nsgi 11y agoThe Heimlich manoeuvre worked on none of them, because they died. It might have been possible to prevent some of those deaths with wider or more effective provision, but that would also have costs.
- mhb 11y agoI'm thinking that there is quite a bit of cost saved by posting a sheet of paper explaining the Heimlich maneuver instead of installing one of these devices. Give out free smoke detectors with the saved money.
- nsgi 11y agoIf saving thousands of lives was that easy, someone would probably have already done it. Edit: Not saying it couldn't help, but I don't think it's reasonable to assume most of those lives could be saved by putting some posters up unless you have some evidence.
- chrisfosterelli 11y agoJust because they died doesn't mean someone: 1) Did the Heimlich manoeuvre 2) Performed it properly 3) Continued proper behaviour after the Heimlich manoeuvre failed There is a good chance the people who died were alone, that everyone around them panicked and froze up, or that nobody realized the person was in danger (people who choke are actually more likely to leave the room than try to tell someone). People often don't call 911 until it's too late. I do see the OP's point that potentially education and teaching of what to actually do in these scenarios would be more effective than buying a vast number of these devices. I took a first aid course and I can say that while the majority of people know what the Heimlich manoeuvre is, I don't believe they'd behave properly in a chocking situation. That said, I think these should definitely be put to trial runs to find out :)
- nsgi 11y agoMy point is that I don't think that's a problem that can be solved with a few posters. It doesn't matter if the deaths could have technically been prevented with the Heimlich manoeuvre unless there's a cheap and practical way to get people to perform it properly.
- mhb 11y agoSo you think a problem that can't be solved with a picture of someone helping someone choking by grabbing them from behind and squeezing can be solved by having them find this gadget and figuring out how to use it? Curious.
- chrisfosterelli 11y agoI agree that I doubt posters would help. People need proper first aid training. That said, the same logic applies to this device.
- chazu 11y agoThe device(s) in question are merely syringes with masks and a tube connected. If we assume that the average citizen in the developed world is OK with current levels of spending on public health with respect to emergency medical treatment, I doubt that a device such as this would necessitate concerns about "at what cost" any given number of lives are being saved. In other words, dude its 150 bucks!
- mhb 11y agoThat's reasonable when deciding whether to get one for your house. Not so much when deciding whether it's generally a good value compared to other ways of saving lives. Then we're talking about ($150 x n)/(lives saved compared to the alternatives). Before you advocate it, maybe you should get an idea what n and the denominator are.
- moogleii 11y agoEvery restaurant in NYC seems to have a defibrillator, so it could be doable.
- mhb 11y agoWhat's the cost/benefit of those?
- paulmd 11y agoIf you're the guy on the ground in cardiac arrest? Priceless. Just checked Amazon - you can buy an AED for $959 minus $100 coupon. The recommended lifespan of an AED is 5-8 years, so for a smalltime operator you're looking at an amortized cost of $107-175 per year. $10 per month is a rounding error in the operating budget of a public accomodation, and I don't see how you can possibly get upset about that. Let alone something like a ship that's multiple hours away from the closest possible medevac. A container ship likely burns more fuel than that in an hour of operation. Won't someone please think of poor Maersk's quarterly profits? Or even worse, my Amazon crap might cost another $0.01 per tonne... Even if you don't care that it's The Right Thing To Do, the cold truth is that if someone dies there's tons of expensive things that happen. If an employee dies there's insurance or comp to pay, there's the cost of hiring a replacement and so on, etc. And on a social level we lose their economic output and its effect on the aggregate economy.
- mhb 11y agoSurely you understand that this reasoning must break down for some cost of AED. Presumably you have them in your home and office. Yes?