3 ms·
Agreed. Modern cars, even the modest ones, are fast enough that they can get out of control very quickly. While the brakes certainly can slow a vehicle with it
by alistairSH 11y ago
Agreed.
Modern cars, even the modest ones, are fast enough that they can get out of control very quickly. While the brakes certainly can slow a vehicle with its throttle stuck open, the real question is what impact does that stuck throttle have on the average driver? When the brake doesn't work as expected, does the average driver continue to brake? Do they pump the brake pedal? Something else altogether? How long does it take them to regain composure and act sensibly (in this case, putting the car in neutral while continuing to brake aggressively)? If that slowed reaction is more than some fraction of a second, accidents will happen.
- mikeash 11y agoIt's likely that drivers won't immediately react well to unintended acceleration. However, immediate reactions are unlikely to cause major accidents here. Yeah, you might bump someone or mount a curb or something, but it's likely to be an injury-free accident. Toyota's unintended acceleration is notorious because of incidents where the car accelerated up to extremely high speeds, was driven down the highway in this state for an extended time, then finally crashed. At least one involved a panicked 911 call from the driver. This is a scenario drivers should be able to bring to a safe conclusion, because they have time to work things out. Some drivers will panic in such a scenario and be unable to work on the problem. Those people should not be driving. That they are speaks to the woefully inadequate state of driver training in this country. None of this absolves Toyota of blame, though. If an equipment malfunction due to a design defect results in death even if the human should have recovered, that's still the fault of the manufacturer, as well as the driver.
- kps 11y ago> Do they pump the brake pedal? A comment below mentions this, and it's one factor that can be age-related without invoking ‘dumb old people pressed the accelerator by mistake’. People who learned to drive before ABS were taught to pump the brakes.
- alistairSH 11y agoI hadn't even thought of pre-ABS drivers being taught to pump the pedal to avoid skidding. I was thinking of my old race car days, where a low pedal (boiled fluid or worse) could be temporarily reversed by a few pedal pumps to bring up the line pressure.