5 ms·
The key point is that technology have increasingly replaced not just manual labour but also replaced higher and higher levels of abstracted thinking. I.e. tec
by ThomPete 11y ago
The key point is that technology have increasingly replaced not just manual labour but also replaced higher and higher levels of abstracted thinking.
I.e. technology now is gunning for competing with our brains too not just our muscle.
The problem with the discussion is that people often assume that it will only happen if we create robots that are as general purpose as ourselves. However no one uses everything they are to do their jobs. And so a lot of people from radiologist to factory workers will find themselves out of a job with no realistic way to re-educate themselves into areas that require them.
The horses lost to the cars and didn't find new jobs.
I don't know if technology is going to take over all the jobs but it is going to take over enough that it will require all nations to rethink society.
The longer that discussion is brushed aside the harder it's going to be to change.
- johngalt 11y agoThis comment sounds like the short version of 'humans need not apply' by cgp grey.
- ThomPete 11y agoI just saw the video another commenter posted it. I guess cgp and me are in agreement then :)
- ggrothendieck 11y agoThe link is set to start at 3:22 but its the whole Humans video if you start from the beginning.
- netcan 11y ago"The horses lost to the cars and didn't find new jobs" That's a good line. I hope you don't mind if I pinch it. I agree that there is not obvious rule in economics stating that most humans must remain employed. I also agree that without close to full employment (say long term >80% of people that want/need jobs) the basic economic and political paradigms we have no longer work. I'm kind of agnostic whether or not we are headed there. Technology taking skill out of the equation like in Adam Smith's famous pin example is somewhat similar to driverless cars. Generally technology has affected the demand for labour all throughout history, and it's affected the demand for labour of all kinds. We used to need musicians to listen to music, bars & cinemas employed them. Is that brain power or manual labour? We used to need engineers to do calculations by hand. Demand for engineers stayed high because we just do more engineering. Also, in my agnosticism, I think there's a bunch of room for middle ground outcomes. Unemployment that stays around 30%, for example. That is also a political paradigm shift. I don't expect we'll soon run out of demand or that people will not have an effect on our productive capacity. But perhaps the bar for economic productivity will be higher. That's potentially a problem.
- ThomPete 11y agoBy all means please do :) With regards to jobs see this graph. https://plot.ly/~BethS/8/job-growth-by-decade-in-the-united-states/ https://plot.ly/~BethS/8/job-growth-by-decade-in-the-united-... Job creation is falling each decade so it's not true as some claim that technology just creates new jobs. Well it does but globally not domestically. Or in other words. The west has lost jobs both to the east and to automation and not gained enough new ones. The primary issue right now in my view seems to be that technology is now changing things so fast that it's not possible for people to re-educate themselves. This is one of the major issues whether on is agnostic or not. But we will see.
- ggrothendieck 11y agoThis video discusses horse unemployment and more: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Pq-S557XQU&t=3m32s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Pq-S557XQU&t=3m32s
- ThomPete 11y agoOh wow hah. Nice!