3 ms·
Startup Says It Can Make Ethanol for $1 a Gallon, and Without Corn
- hugh 19y agoInteresting technology. There's no reason why it shouldn't work, and if it does, it'll be great. But the numbers in the article don't quite seem to work out. The first "commercial-scale" plant in 2011 will only make 100,000 gallons a year. Assuming they make it for $1 a gallon in raw materials and sell it for $3 a gallon, you've still got a chemical plant whose gross profit is barely enough to employ two people. Is that really "commercial scale"?
- rms 19y agoYeah... I saw that too. Sounds more like a test scale production, or someone forgot two zeros. Wired seems to be slipping lately; there was an article they published that said you can get a whole human genome sequenced today for $10,000 which is very wrong. And if it's not wrong, I want to know where. http://www.wired.com/science/discoveries/news/2008/01/synthetic_genome?currentPage=2 http://www.wired.com/science/discoveries/news/2008/01/synthe...
- hugh 19y agoOK, I googled "coskata 2011", and all other sources say they're planning to make 50-100 _million_ gallons a year by 2011, which makes much more sense. For what it's worth, the total US consumption of gasoline is about 140 billion gallons a year.
- Tichy 19y agoSo it makes sense that they'll singlehandedly take over 70% of the gasoline consumption of the US within 3 years? Without applying any mathematical tricks or bayesian reasoning or whatever, I'd say off the top of my head that that is very unlikely.
- Tichy 19y agoIt doesn't sound so revolutionary when they mention that current processes cost only 1,40$ a gallon. Also, to claim "it does not interfer with food production because it does not need corn" seems plain wrong. Whatever plant they'll be using will be taking away space that could otherwise have been used for growing food.
- hugh 19y agoYes, but there's a lot of marginal semi-arid land out there which is no good for producing crops, but fine for producing something like the switchgrass they're thinking of using.
- hugh 19y agoOh yeah, and also (replying to myself here) you can use the waste products which you get from crop production anyway -- e.g. the stalks and leaves -- so it can work in parallel with food production. That stuff currently has negative value -- farmers will pay you to take it off their land.