4 ms·
(1) doesn't apply to the actual results of the study reported, which finds the (oft-found) effect that boys from low socioeconomic groups (not the middle class)
by XorNot 11y ago
(1) doesn't apply to the actual results of the study reported, which finds the (oft-found) effect that boys from low socioeconomic groups (not the middle class) are disproportionately disadvantaged compared to their female peers.
The usual explanation tends to be that the outs in progression to university-level education are much more available to young men than women overall, as well as the worst excesses of lost potential (i.e. gang membership and fatalities are disproportionately male).
(2) demands actual evidence, since the implication that male teachers will, what? allow things to escalate to physical violence? Hardly belies any real improvement in teaching outcomes.
(4) also demands actual evidence.
- bsder 11y agoEvidence? Mostly personal experience of my own teaching along with my parents who both taught. > (2) demands actual evidence, since the implication that male teachers will, what? allow things to escalate to physical violence? Hardly belies any real improvement in teaching outcomes. There are two pieces to this. One is physical and one is social. As for physical: if I'm managing a classroom, I have a lot of authority by virtue of being 6"+, 100bs+ bigger than most of the students. My voice alone is far more powerful than that of a woman. In addition, I can embarrass or insult a troublemaker without much fear of physical repercussion. This is really huge as it gives me a lot of graded options that a woman would have to think twice about. And, at bottom, the students have to wonder exactly how much damage I could do to them if they really push me into a corner. As for social: my personal experience is that a lot of female teachers want compliance (personal control dynamic) while male teachers can function as long as there is no interference (group outcome dynamic). A good example of this was an exchange between my parents: <female> "I want them to quit chewing tobacco in my class" (Note: personal control dynamic). <male> "Well, you're not going to get that without throwing somebody out of class every day. Are you willing to disrupt your class for that?" <female> "Not really." <male> "Okay, so presumably you could ignore it if they don't spit in the back of the class (group outcome dynamic)?" <female> "I guess, but ..." <male> "Fine. That's achievable by telling them: "If you're man enough to chew, you're man enough to swallow it (Note: peer embarrassment). If I see any on the floor, all the people I see chewing are cleaning it." Now they'll police each other, and you'll only occasionally have to send one to the office." > there are a LOT of female teachers that actively try to gain their student's approval. Go teach at a school. There are always quite a few women who want to be "buds" with the students. I don't really see this among the men except in the genuinely dangerous cases.
- Benichmt1 11y agoIn regards to your point about the physical size being a thing: I worked at an inner city school and one of the teachers that could get students in line like nobody else was a 6'5" 275 lb man who worked as a biker bar bouncer on weekends. This was middle school, so maybe the effect was exaggerated, but he could stop fights like no other. To your point about trying to gain the approval of students, the dynamic definitely makes a big difference. Teachers that tried to be the 'fun' teacher were taken advantage of time and time again. I wish this wasn't the case, but an authoritarian role was the best way to provide consistency, stability, and true opportunity for learning in these types of classrooms.