3 ms·
I would argue the opposite. You can't provide an equality of access that meets any given standard of fairness without creating inequality, because now you are
by dnautics 11y ago
I would argue the opposite. You can't provide an equality of access that meets any given standard of fairness without creating inequality, because now you are favoring those who happen to conform to/ or be better suited to/ or have a better temperament for the new standard over the old.
- unclebucknasty 11y agoBut, this begs the question, as it assumes equality or fairness in the old standard. The point seems to be that this is not the case, thus provisions are required as a means of correction.
- dnautics 11y agono such assumption. The statement at the end is that there in inequality created at the end. I.E. there will be winners and losers. Now you could argue that the 'right correction' would create the 'right winners and right losers' but I think historically, almost all of the best-intentioned corrections applied by the states have ultimately hurt the dispossessed.
- dragonwriter 11y agoYou may say that's the opposite, but to me, its two sides of the same coin -- and its a fairly significant problem in achieving anything satisfying the common desire for fairness. If equality of access is fair, it produces inequality of outcome, but inequality of outcome itself destroys equality of access. There's no stable equilibrium that is fair, achieving fairness, to the degree that is possible, requires constant monitoring and active balancing.