5 ms·
There are a couple people picking on this research in the thread. This is a preliminary study, just a "bullshit test" to see if this woman is crazy or if she's
by klodolph 11y ago
There are a couple people picking on this research in the thread. This is a preliminary study, just a "bullshit test" to see if this woman is crazy or if she's not. It's obvious that she's not crazy, because all she's doing is sniffing t-shirts and she doesn't know who they belong to. The sample size is large enough, we have a p-value of no more than p=0.0012, and that's under the cynical assumption that she somehow knew that exactly seven of the twelve samples would have Parkinson's... something that the scientists didn't know.
So we know that something is going on here. The next steps are to control potential confounding variables and to determine the sensitivity and specificity of the test, if it's shown that she's not actually detecting some confounding variable. This is where you go double-blind, you use larger sample sizes, et cetera, now that you have money. You have money because the preliminary research was promising.
And we're not just getting a good test out of this. If there's an actual chemical that she's smelling, then there's some chemical process that's going on in people with Parkinson's which isn't happening in people without Parkinson's (or vice versa). Tracing these chemical pathways could give us clues to the etiology of the disease, which would be a REALLY BIG DEAL. Or maybe it's just a rabbit hole.
- cbd1984 11y agoOne of the great things about science is that we can determine whether a phenomenon is likely real without having to have the slightest clue what the mechanism might be. Evidence comes first, and this looks like solid evidence, and mechanism can come later; the evidence alone proves the existence of something interesting, and that's what's worth a follow-up. Hypothesis generation is important, because it helps us design the next experiment, but this experiment is already very interesting.
- nnethercote 11y ago> One of the great things about science is that we can determine whether a phenomenon is likely real without having to have the slightest clue what the mechanism might be. You just have to ignore the people who shout "correlation is not causation" at every opportunity, appropriate or not.
- georgemcbay 11y agoThere should be a name for those people who are quick to shout out some truism (that is actually true) but used out of context to a cliched degree. See also: "You're not Google's customer, you're the product"
- 0xcde4c3db 11y agoSee also also: argument from fallacy, aka the "fallacy fallacy": claiming that a conclusion is wrong because an argument supporting it is invalid.
- sangnoir 11y agoNot disagreeing, but there is a fine-line between an argument being wrong and that the conclusion being wrong. Are you really right when you use an incorrect argument/process/information to arrive to the right conclusion? There's a whole epistemological debate to be had about the intersection of belief, knowledge and truth.
- Pharaoh2 11y agoBecause "correlation is not causation" is just plain wrong. What is should be is "correlation does not imply causation". This is where science comes in. To answer the question, is this correlation because of causation? The statement is only important to people doing statistical analysis not experimental science.
- coldtea 11y ago>correlation does not imply causation It sure does. It might not prove causation, or it might not necessitate causation, but it very much implies it. Somehow people forget that "imply" means: "indicate the truth or existence of (something) by suggestion rather than explicit reference". In this -- the dictionary and everyday sense -- correlation DOES imply (suggest) causation. It just doesn't secure it.
- 11y ago