5 ms·
This makes sense. It's not that we should all be uniform but rather we all have access to being uniform if we so choose. Even if we attempted equality, time w
by mc32 11y ago
This makes sense. It's not that we should all be uniform but rather we all have access to being uniform if we so choose.
Even if we attempted equality, time would introduce inequality due to the risks people take. One invests wisely, the other gambles away. Do we compensate the gambler to reestablish equilibrium?
Should a soon to be retiree have the same wealth or earning power as a new graduate of X degree, or even a dropout?
Maybe we should compensate workers based on responsibilities (ie dependents, that, in some ways would be fairer, the woman with three dependent children gets paid more than the man with one, but the man with two where one requires extra care gets paid more than either, to compensate for added medical expenses)
- walshemj 11y agoWhich is explicitly not Fair
- mc32 11y agoNot fair in what context to whom?
- walshemj 11y agoYou really need me to tell you this? should we allocate votes on that basis? Hint think how single people will see this.
- mc32 11y agoYou see fairness and equality arrive at different conclusions, so my point is fairness can seem unfair, depending how we slice fair. Still, one can argue pay based on need is quite fair, if not fairer than simple equality.
- ionforce 11y agoThere's no guarantee that the parents would be spending their added income on these dependents.
- jbuzbee 11y agoMaybe we should compensate workers based on responsibilities (ie dependents I was following you up until this notion. Compensation has nothing to do with a worker's responsibilities. Compensation is based on how much the job is worth to the person or company paying. That's why a brain-surgeon with no dependents is paid more than a ditch-digger with a house full of kids.
- mc32 11y agoI understand, and this is out current model, but some argue for income equality, so I ask what kind of equality? Let's have goals before we discuss the merits.
- thaumasiotes 11y ago> Even if we attempted equality, time would introduce inequality due to the risks people take. One invests wisely, the other gambles away. Do we compensate the gambler to reestablish equilibrium? You just assumed the gambler ended up worse off. What if he won? Do we compensate the investor for his sub-risky-gambling return?
- mc32 11y agoEither way, what do we do with people who take a chance on their own volition and lose perennially? Do we compensate for losses to keep things equal?
- thaumasiotes 11y agoHow could you possibly justify that if you're not willing to juice the investor's gains when the gambler comes out ahead?