3 ms·
To me, it's just as big a deal that you're now at the whim of the provider. Your equipment can suddenly stop working if: * They go out of business or decide to
by gregmac 11y ago
To me, it's just as big a deal that you're now at the whim of the provider. Your equipment can suddenly stop working if:
* They go out of business or decide to drop the product line
* Their servers go down (do you know if they're running a HA config, or merely a single server?)
* They decide to make v2 of the product and stop updating/supporting v1
On top of this, your home internet connection can and will go down. Depending on what exactly you're doing this may or may not be a big deal: for example, not being able to remotely see your garage door status probably isn't important. Not having your motion sensing lights or timed schedules work, however, would be a pain.
There are many products from startups that are hurting themselves because of this. I, like many geeks, love this kind of stuff, but like you, I won't purchase or make my house rely on anything that has these risks, and I steer friends and family away from these products as well.
Developers: At least make your internet connection optional and allow the gear work without it. Even better, open source your server software: we can see how secure it is, plus if you go out of business, I can at least run it myself.
- fnordfnordfnord 11y ago>Your equipment can suddenly stop working if... That's part of what makes it a weak link! >your home internet connection can and will go down Yup
- geographomics 11y agoI had exactly that problem with a digital photo frame. Company went out of business a few months after purchase, leaving no way to update the displayed photos (at least, not without hacking the device) as they were all pulled from a remote server that no longer existed.
- CaptSpify 11y agoThis is why I've been working with rpi/arduino stuff: I can build it myself. Sure, it's more work, but the pre-built options all suck, as far as I've seen. I used to always follow the newest automation releases, but I gave up, because they were all closed-source, internet-required devices. Screw that.