63 ms·
> It's amazing how many people think that Quantum Mechanic's > "two states" (e.g. in the Schrödinger's cat example [1]) > just mean "it's actually in
by wodenokoto 11y ago
> It's amazing how many people think that Quantum Mechanic's
> "two states" (e.g. in the Schrödinger's cat example [1])
> just mean "it's actually in one state, and we just don't
> know which until we look".
Why is that amazing? Seems like the absolutely most simple and logical conclusion. In the Schrödinger's Cat example, there the only reason to assume the cat is in a dual state is if you want to make a more complex interpretation of the situation.
- coldtea 11y ago>Seems like the absolutely most simple and logical conclusion. It's simple, logical and wrong. The idea with the cat was to magnify (in the macro world) a quantum phenomenon from the micro-world were the state of the object is absolutely and measurably NOT "either/or". It's both (all) states at the same time. >In the Schrödinger's Cat example, there the only reason to assume the cat is in a dual state is if you want to make a more complex interpretation of the situation. No, the reason to assume the cat is in a dual state is that the particle determining its fate IS in a dual state (superposition), a state contrary to everyday intuition. Now, you could say that the cat is dead or alive in some split one of "infinite universes" or a few other explanations, e.g. that we have collapsed to a single state earlier for some reason, but not the crude dead-or-alive-we-just-don't-know-yet thing in a single physical universe...
- wodenokoto 11y ago> It's simple, logical and wrong. It doesn't matter if it is wrong, it is still the simplest explanation to Schrödinger's Cat. So there is nothing amazing about people arguing for that view. Saying that it is actually the particle that is in a super position doesn't change anything, since we cannot observe the super position. Therefore the particle can also be assumed to be in 1 of 2 states, which is yet to be determined. Nothing about the situation requires anything to be in a superposition. So again, my point is that there is absolutely nothing amazing about people still holding on to the classical view.
- jng 11y agoThe amazing thing is that then you have no explanation to the real, practical, measurable results of the two-slit experiment. You know, there's a reason for why many intelligent people with some understanding of physics and logic decided to drop the classical view.
- digi_owl 11y agoIirc, you can replicate the two-slit effect using drops of oil on water. This by introducing a wave in the water and watch it carry the oil drops as distinct units. Except that such a (pilot) wave is exactly the kind of hidden variable that Bell's theorem disputes.
- coldtea 11y ago>It doesn't matter if it is wrong, it is still the simplest explanation to Schrödinger's Cat. No, it's the simplest explanation to "we have a cat in the box, and a poison released optionally, is the cat dead or alive" question. Which is different than the actual question posed by the experiment, where "optionally" depends on a very specific and non intuitive process. So it's an answer all right, and simple too, but not the question proposed, as it fails to take into account everything asked.
- jberryman 11y ago> It's both (all) states at the same time. So what does that entail? Isn't this philosophy of science?
- wfn 11y agoThe cat was first invoked as a kind-of-mocking thought experiment and a point of critique towards (the Copenhagen interpretation of) QM, IIRC. (The answer to the thought is that yes, indeed, the cat would already be in a single state prior to observation, because the large macro system would have decohered and collapsed into a single state prior to an observer checking the status of the system.. unless I'm mixing something up.)
- Filligree 11y agoNo, that is indeed what would happen in practice, but it's theoretically possible to prevent decoherence even in a system this large. The thought experiment was about this, theoretical possibility.