3 ms·
Money's essentially an arrangement between people. If say you do a sketch on a bit of paper and I buy it off you for $1m in the form of another bit of paper say
by tim333 11y ago
Money's essentially an arrangement between people. If say you do a sketch on a bit of paper and I buy it off you for $1m in the form of another bit of paper saying IOU $1m then in a sense you have $1m in Tim bonds and can then use that to buy a car with another IOU backed by my bonds, or cash backed by them if someone will lend you the cash. The whole thing can fall apart if one loses confidence in the value of the debts though. What you see in the markets with currency creation and crises are all essentially more complicated variations of the above.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- netcan 11y agoThis is a kind of an economist's version of events. It's not wrong, but it is a narrative so it's useful for thinking about things in ways that economists are interested in, not necessarily every way. Debt as the origin of money kind of dates to the time when economists were thinking about these things more than the time when money was invented. Money was invented lots of times. A common form is when there is a lot of trade and people start trading in particular things specifically for their tradability. Those things are then money. No promises involved. In some cases there is evidence of promises as early money. Cattle or wheat and traded for clay artifacts and traded back at will could. This allowed traders to exchange clay coins instead of actual goods which is ore convenient. But, I think this is an exception. Modern money often evolved from promises to pay bearers gold or other currencies and eventually the promise was removed. Back to the narrative… For my own narrative, I think of money like this. Money is a tool for massive and complex cooperation in large groups, a fundamentally human talent. It's emergent and the behavior that encourages its emergence is massive and complex cooperation in ways that require it, trade basically. If enough trade is happening, I think money emerges in some form and it enables even more trade.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI think you just took a step backwards by declaring money as "emergent". The two models sketched before were providing additional details - what particular conditions cause money to appear and why. Saying it sort of emerges when there's enough trade is zooming out.