6 ms·
I agree. The other day, I stood in the supermarket contemplating the 20 different types of Colgate toothpaste. Did I want Whitening? No. Sensitive Teeth? No. T
by Angostura 11y ago
I agree. The other day, I stood in the supermarket contemplating the 20 different types of Colgate toothpaste.
Did I want Whitening? No. Sensitive Teeth? No. Those were easy choices. What about the Anti-Cavity version? Now that sounds good. But, but I also have some gum disease, so perhaps Gum Care is the right choice? But what about the formulation that promised Harder Teeth?
Perhaps I should just get Colgate Total. But does Total have as much anti-cavity stuff as the Anti-Cavity variant? does it have as much as much gum care stuff as the Gum Care variant? It costs the same as both, so maybe its kind of a bit of everything and not as good as anything.
In the end I bought Aquafresh. In the old days I thought that Total was the best I could get - now I'm not so sure.
- buro9 11y agoI have done that same dance too many times.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoMy ex-girlfriend had the opposite problem. She stood in the market and contemplated only a few choices in shampoo - basically regular and hair fall rescue. She went with regular. Her hair got all messed up - apparently Indian and African hair are actually very different and Africans actually need fancy African shampoo. At the end of the day she did have only one choice - cut her hair short and spend 1000rs/month (plus about 6 hours) having a Nigerian woman give her an (illegal) weave. Choice sucks when you are part of the majority who's needs are catered to.
- pjc50 11y ago(illegal) weave Illegal hairstyles? There has to be a bizarre story behind this.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoOccupational licensing and immigration restrictions mean black ladies need to turn to the black market. Even in the US this is an issue: http://madamenoire.com/501738/texas-federal-judge-rules-hair-braiding-laws-unconstitutional/ http://madamenoire.com/501738/texas-federal-judge-rules-hair...
- tvanantwerp 11y agoExample of the absurdity of occupational licensing in regard to hair: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2tjTheDqQrw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2tjTheDqQrw
- jarek 11y agoWould love to hear what sort of minority the choice of Colgate Total vs Colgate Anti-Cavity caters to
- jtuente 11y agoAllergens, minor genetic mutations, mouth feel, flavor, aftertaste, scent. Me? I just buy the prettiest box, not necessarily the shiniest.
- cubano 11y agoWow, I just happened to go through that last night. I selected the Crest 3D White after the same torturous 5 minutes :) But I'm not sure all that choice made my life any worse for the ware, and I'm naturally suspicious of any heavy-handed solutions to keep them from us. Let the market decide...in the end, I just can't imagine all those types of toothpaste will survive.
- kardos 11y ago> Let the market decide...in the end, I just can't imagine all those types of toothpaste will survive. The idea that the "market will decide" is based on people in aggregate making informed decisions, such that the poor products fail. The reality is that people are not masters of every domain, toothpaste choices are basically arbitrary, but it's more time consuming to inspect 30 options than to inspect 5. Also there is the practise of building one manufacturing line and selling the product under multiple brands [1], giving you "artificial" choice. If we're going to reduce choice, starting with these would be low hanging fruit. [1] http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB117867462888496739 http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB117867462888496739
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoThat's an interesting observation! "The market" is aware of how we make decisions. Its no accident there are too many choices, thus we can't keep them all in our heads, so we can't ever find the best or worst brand. That's got to be intended!
- kardos 11y ago> That's got to be intended! More or less. I'd say it's a "solution" that the market found for the race-to-the-bottom problem.
- cubano 11y ago>Also there is the practise of building one manufacturing line and selling the product under multiple brands [1], giving you "artificial" choice. Ok, so what is your solution? It should seem just as obvious that having some sort of regulated toothpaste market is also a form of "artificial choice" ie someone(s) somewhere are limiting it.
- dazc 11y ago"... I thought that Total was the best I could get - now I'm not so sure." I used to think this too but when they started introducing multiple variants I switched to Oral B Pro Expert. It was a no brainer because Pro Expert was fast becoming the new 'best you could get'. Alas Pro Expert has also now morphed into many variations on the same theme. My hygienist however, who's devotion to dental hygiene is beyond question, has never asked me what brand of toothpaste I use?
- wlesieutre 11y agoAziz Ansari has a great bit about this. Excerpt: >Why do we always want the best? I had to get a toothbrush the other day. Before I left my house, I searched “best toothbrush.” It seemed like the sensible thing to do. >As I typed in the searchbox, the auto-fill completed the thought immediately. I wasn’t alone in my toothbrush purchase insecurity. A flurry of articles came up with conflicting opinions and, for a moment, I felt stupid. >Every toothbrush I bought on a hunch has been fine. I’ve never been disappointed in a toothbrush. Why waste my time trying to find the best? Have you ever run into someone with no teeth and asked, “What happened?” >And they replied, “Bought the wrong toothbrush. Should have done more research.” Full transcript: http://cultivatingthought.com/author/aziz-ansari/ http://cultivatingthought.com/author/aziz-ansari/ (scroll down to the white background)
- throwaway7767 11y agoI can't agree that toothbrushes are all the same. Some irritate my gums more than others. On some the brushes deform so fast they last a very short time. So I would say that choice in toothbrush matters, for me. Same for toothpaste, largely because of taste. Most of it has this terrible taste, I prefer the ones with an added mint taste that hides the other stuff. That said, I don't think for a second that searching for "best toothbrush" or "best toothpaste" on google is likely to answer the question, which would I prefer? You just have to try different things until you find the one you like, and hope the company doesn't rename its whole product line in two months. Choice is good. There is rarely an objectively "best" version of anything.
- mikk14 11y agoIf it makes feel you better, it doesn't matter. Last day I was comparing the ingredients of the whitening vs non-whitening of another brand (don't remember which), and not only the active ingredient was the same, it was also present in the exact same quantity. It was literally the same toothpaste. I'd assume Colgate does the same.
- pnut 11y agoColgate tastes like sugar to me, I can't use it at all.
- fmueller 11y agoIt's important to know that most people make this choice once in a lifetime. After that they'll buy the same product until they die. I'm pretty sure you'll buy Aquafresh from now on if you like it. So choice is difficult the first time but the next time it will be easy. That's the reason why it's important to advertise children as early as possible. Because once they decided on a product it's very hard to convince them of something better.
- Angostura 11y agoThe point is that I've been buying toothpaste from Colgate pretty much for my entire life. The manufacturers attempt to segment the market just drove me away. And that segmentation ensures that it isn't just a once a lifetime choice. Each to time I look at the Colgate shelf I have to consider what is more important to me this week - the state of my gums or the likelihood of cavities.
- greeneggs 11y agoThe manufacturers aren't trying to segment the market. They are trying to claim shelf space. (The amount of Colgate they sell is proportional to the shelf space the store offers them, which is proportional to the number of varieties they offer.) If Colgate had only one variety and Crest had ten varieties, then Crest would get that much more shelf space and vastly outsell Colgate. Grocery stores also like to offer their customers the illusion of choice, while dealing with as few distributors as possible. This simplifies their logistics. They would prefer to sell ten varieties of Colgate and Crest than ten separate brands of toothpaste. It gets ridiculous when you see half an aisle of Wheat Thins (original, whole wheat, low salt, spicy, plus the store clone brand of each of those). But I suppose the nice consequence is that small corner markets can have just as good a selection, effectively, as huge superstores.
- aidenn0 11y agoI wish... I'm only 35 and I've had to change deoderant 4 times due to my preferred brand and scent disappearing. Toothpaste is a bit better with it only having happened twice.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- sgustard 11y agoEvery variant of Colgate has the same active ingredients. http://www.colgatetotal.com/health-benefits/toothpaste-ingredients http://www.colgatetotal.com/health-benefits/toothpaste-ingre... The only difference appears to be 0.14% vs 0.15% w/v fluoride ion. The naturopathic folks will tell you that triclosan is toxic and you should avoid the mainstream brands altogether.
- jameshart 11y agoCrest doesn't use triclosan, if you are remotely concerned (there's some research showing a link to propensity for allergies, so that might be a reason to avoid it, but the consensus seems far from conclusive)