3 ms·
Actually all we have is faddy unrigorous hobbyisms, mediocre tools, and poor management. If everyone did what Praxis does software would work more reliably, bu
by TheOtherHobbes 11y ago
Actually all we have is faddy unrigorous hobbyisms, mediocre tools, and poor management.
If everyone did what Praxis does software would work more reliably, but there would be far fewer programmers and - crucially - far fewer projects of all kinds.
We have the software industry we have because businesses don't want to pay for a better industry. It's the classic "worse is better" dilemma.
If software were rigorous, the initial cost of many projects would make them look prohibitively expensive. You can try to argue that total costs, including fixes and maintenance, are much lower, but not many managers are going to pay n times more for a project up front in the hope the cost will be n times less over its lifetime - even if there's a serious risk of paying millions or billions and literally getting nothing of use, as regularly happens on very big contracts.
Eventually quality would get cheaper. But for now it's as if the entire field is drowning in technical debt, buried under me-too frameworks and languages that do very little to genuinely improve productivity or reliability, supported by "Take the money, promise everything, and hope for the best" commercial attitudes.
Unfortunately you'd have to wipe out so many languages, techniques, ideas, systems, practices, and management attitudes, and put so many people out of work - or force them into retraining - that the kind of bug rates Praxis produce are never going to be possible across the industry as a whole.